JEE Challenger
More from Moving Charges and Magnetism

Zero Magnetic Field on Loop Axis Due to Loop and Parallel Wires

Comprehension Passage

As illustrated in the diagram, a circular conducting loop of radius aa lies in the plane of the paper along with two long parallel wires (labeled 1 and 2). Both wires are situated at a distance dd from the center of the loop. Each wire as well as the circular loop carries an identical current II. Looking from above, the current circulating in the loop flows in the counterclockwise direction.

Passage Diagram 1

In the case where d≈ad \approx a (with the wires remaining electrically insulated from the circular loop), the total magnetic field vanishes on the axis of the loop at a vertical height hh above its plane. Under these conditions:

Options

A

the currents in wire 1 and wire 2 are directed along PQ\text{PQ} and RS\text{RS}, respectively, and h≈ah \approx a

B

the currents in wire 1 and wire 2 are directed along PQ\text{PQ} and SR\text{SR}, respectively, and h≈ah \approx a

C

the currents in wire 1 and wire 2 are directed along PQ\text{PQ} and SR\text{SR}, respectively, and h≈1.2ah \approx 1.2a

Correct
D

the currents in wire 1 and wire 2 are directed along PQ\text{PQ} and RS\text{RS}, respectively, and h≈1.2ah \approx 1.2a

Step-by-Step Solution

To find the direction of the currents and the height hh at which the total magnetic field vanishes, we set up a Cartesian coordinate system:

  • Let the plane of the paper be the xyxy-plane, with the center of the circular loop at the origin (0,0,0)(0, 0, 0).
  • The axis of the loop lies along the zz-axis, where "above the plane" corresponds to the positive zz-direction (+k^+\hat{k}).
  • Wire 1 lies along the line x=−dx = -d, parallel to the yy-axis (directed from P\text{P} to Q\text{Q}).
  • Wire 2 lies along the line x=+dx = +d, parallel to the yy-axis (with points R\text{R} and S\text{S} along it).

1. Magnetic Field Due to the Circular Loop

The current II in the loop flows counterclockwise as viewed from above (looking down along the −z-z direction). By the right-hand rule, the magnetic field along the loop's axis at a height hh (z=hz = h) points in the +k^+\hat{k} direction:

B⃗loop=μ0Ia22(a2+h2)3/2k^\vec{B}_{\text{loop}} = \frac{\mu_0 I a^2}{2(a^2 + h^2)^{3/2}} \hat{k}

2. Magnetic Field Due to the Parallel Wires

For the net magnetic field on the axis at (0,0,h)(0, 0, h) to be zero, the combined magnetic field of the two wires, B⃗wires\vec{B}_{\text{wires}}, must be directed entirely along −k^-\hat{k} to cancel B⃗loop\vec{B}_{\text{loop}}, meaning any horizontal component must sum to zero.

Let the position vectors of the field point (0,0,h)(0, 0, h) relative to Wire 1 and Wire 2 be:

r⃗1=di^+hk^,r1=d2+h2\vec{r}_1 = d\hat{i} + h\hat{k}, \quad r_1 = \sqrt{d^2 + h^2} r⃗2=−di^+hk^,r2=d2+h2\vec{r}_2 = -d\hat{i} + h\hat{k}, \quad r_2 = \sqrt{d^2 + h^2}
  • If the current in Wire 1 flows along PQ\text{PQ} (the +j^+\hat{j} direction), the magnetic field is:
B⃗1=μ0I2πr12(j^×r⃗1)=μ0I2π(d2+h2)[j^×(di^+hk^)]=μ0I2π(d2+h2)(hi^−dk^)\vec{B}_1 = \frac{\mu_0 I}{2\pi r_1^2} (\hat{j} \times \vec{r}_1) = \frac{\mu_0 I}{2\pi (d^2 + h^2)} \left[ \hat{j} \times (d\hat{i} + h\hat{k}) \right] = \frac{\mu_0 I}{2\pi (d^2 + h^2)} (h\hat{i} - d\hat{k})
  • For the i^\hat{i}-components to cancel and the k^\hat{k}-components to reinforce in the −k^-\hat{k} direction, the current in Wire 2 must be directed along SR\text{SR} (the −j^-\hat{j} direction):
B⃗2=μ0I2πr22(−j^×r⃗2)=μ0I2π(d2+h2)[−j^×(−di^+hk^)]=μ0I2π(d2+h2)(−hi^−dk^)\vec{B}_2 = \frac{\mu_0 I}{2\pi r_2^2} (-\hat{j} \times \vec{r}_2) = \frac{\mu_0 I}{2\pi (d^2 + h^2)} \left[ -\hat{j} \times (-d\hat{i} + h\hat{k}) \right] = \frac{\mu_0 I}{2\pi (d^2 + h^2)} (-h\hat{i} - d\hat{k})

The resultant magnetic field of the two wires is:

B⃗wires=B⃗1+B⃗2=−μ0Idπ(d2+h2)k^\vec{B}_{\text{wires}} = \vec{B}_1 + \vec{B}_2 = -\frac{\mu_0 I d}{\pi (d^2 + h^2)} \hat{k}

Thus, the currents in Wire 1 and Wire 2 must be directed along PQ\text{PQ} and SR\text{SR}, respectively.

3. Calculating the Height hh

Equating the magnitude of the magnetic field from the loop to the magnitude of the field from the wires:

∣B⃗loop∣=∣B⃗wires∣|\vec{B}_{\text{loop}}| = |\vec{B}_{\text{wires}}| μ0Ia22(a2+h2)3/2=μ0Idπ(d2+h2)\frac{\mu_0 I a^2}{2(a^2 + h^2)^{3/2}} = \frac{\mu_0 I d}{\pi (d^2 + h^2)}

Given d≈ad \approx a:

μ0Ia22(a2+h2)3/2=μ0Iaπ(a2+h2)\frac{\mu_0 I a^2}{2(a^2 + h^2)^{3/2}} = \frac{\mu_0 I a}{\pi (a^2 + h^2)}

Simplifying:

a2a2+h2=1π\frac{a}{2\sqrt{a^2 + h^2}} = \frac{1}{\pi} a2+h2=π2a≈3.14162a≈1.57a\sqrt{a^2 + h^2} = \frac{\pi}{2} a \approx \frac{3.1416}{2} a \approx 1.57 a

Squaring both sides:

a2+h2≈(1.57)2a2≈2.467a2a^2 + h^2 \approx (1.57)^2 a^2 \approx 2.467 a^2 h2≈1.467a2  ⟹  h≈1.467a≈1.21a≈1.2ah^2 \approx 1.467 a^2 \implies h \approx \sqrt{1.467} a \approx 1.21 a \approx 1.2a

Therefore, the currents in wire 1 and wire 2 are directed along PQ\text{PQ} and SR\text{SR}, respectively, and h≈1.2ah \approx 1.2a.

Correct Option: C