JEE Challenger
More from Thermal Properties of Matter

Steady State Temperature of Middle Plate Between Ideal Black Surfaces

Three large parallel plates having the same surface area are positioned close to one another. Assuming they behave as ideal blackbodies with very high thermal conductivity, the first and third plates are held at temperatures 2T2T and 3T3T respectively. Determine the temperature of the intermediate plate when a steady state is reached.

Options

A

(652)14T\left(\frac{65}{2}\right)^{\frac{1}{4}} T

B

(974)14T\left(\frac{97}{4}\right)^{\frac{1}{4}} T

C

(972)14T\left(\frac{97}{2}\right)^{\frac{1}{4}} T

Correct
D

(97)14T(97)^{\frac{1}{4}} T

Step-by-Step Solution

To find the steady-state temperature of the intermediate plate, let:

  • T1=2TT_1 = 2T be the temperature of the first plate,
  • T3=3TT_3 = 3T be the temperature of the third plate,
  • T′T' be the steady-state temperature of the intermediate (middle) plate,
  • AA be the surface area of each plate,
  • σ\sigma be the Stefan-Boltzmann constant.

Since the plates are very large, parallel, close to each other, and behave as ideal blackbodies with emissivity ε=1\varepsilon = 1 and absorptivity α=1\alpha = 1, the radiation exchange between adjacent surfaces can be treated as direct transfer with a view factor of approximately 11.

The intermediate plate has very high thermal conductivity, so both of its surfaces are maintained at the same uniform temperature T′T'.

  1. Radiation absorbed by the middle plate:

    • From the first plate (at temperature T1T_1): Pabs, 1=σAT14=σA(2T)4P_{\text{abs, 1}} = \sigma A T_1^4 = \sigma A (2T)^4
    • From the third plate (at temperature T3T_3): Pabs, 3=σAT34=σA(3T)4P_{\text{abs, 3}} = \sigma A T_3^4 = \sigma A (3T)^4
    • Total power absorbed by the middle plate: Pabs=σA[(2T)4+(3T)4]P_{\text{abs}} = \sigma A \left[(2T)^4 + (3T)^4\right]
  2. Radiation emitted by the middle plate: The middle plate emits thermal radiation from both of its surfaces (one facing the first plate and one facing the third plate): Pemit=2σA(T′)4P_{\text{emit}} = 2 \sigma A (T')^4

  3. Steady-state condition: In the steady-state, the net rate of heat transfer to the middle plate must be zero, meaning the total power absorbed must equal the total power emitted: Pabs=PemitP_{\text{abs}} = P_{\text{emit}} σA[(2T)4+(3T)4]=2σA(T′)4\sigma A \left[(2T)^4 + (3T)^4\right] = 2\sigma A (T')^4

    Canceling σA\sigma A from both sides gives: 2(T′)4=(2T)4+(3T)42(T')^4 = (2T)^4 + (3T)^4 2(T′)4=(16+81)T4=97T42(T')^4 = (16 + 81)T^4 = 97T^4 (T′)4=972T4(T')^4 = \frac{97}{2} T^4

    Taking the fourth root on both sides: T′=(972)14TT' = \left(\frac{97}{2}\right)^{\frac{1}{4}} T

Therefore, the correct option is C.