JEE Challenger
More from Ray Optics and Optical Instruments

Reflection of Light Ray Inside Equilateral Triangular Mirror Box

Three plane mirrors form an equilateral triangle with each side of length LL. There is a small hole at a distance l>0l > 0 from one of the corners as shown in the figure. A ray of light is passed through the hole at an angle θ\theta and can only come out through the same hole. The cross section of the mirror configuration and the ray of light lie on the same plane.

Which of the following statement(s) is(are) correct?

Question Diagram 1

Options

A

The ray of light will come out for θ=30\theta = 30^\circ, for 0<l<L0 < l < L.

Correct
B

There is an angle for l=L2l = \frac{L}{2} at which the ray of light will come out after two reflections.

Correct
C

The ray of light will NEVER come out for θ=60\theta = 60^\circ, and l=L3l = \frac{L}{3}.

D

The ray of light will come out for θ=60\theta = 60^\circ, and 0<l<L20 < l < \frac{L}{2} after six reflections.

Step-by-Step Solution

To determine which statement(s) is(are) correct, we analyze the path of the light ray inside the equilateral triangular mirror configuration using coordinate geometry and the law of reflection.

Let the vertices of the equilateral triangle ABCABC of side length LL be placed in a Cartesian coordinate system as:

  • B=(0,0)B = (0, 0)
  • C=(L,0)C = (L, 0)
  • A=(L2,3L2)A = \left(\frac{L}{2}, \frac{\sqrt{3}L}{2}\right)

The equations of the three sides are:

  1. Base BCBC: y=0y = 0 for x[0,L]x \in [0, L]
  2. Left side ABAB: y=3xy = \sqrt{3}x for x[0,L2]x \in \left[0, \frac{L}{2}\right]
  3. Right side ACAC: y=3(Lx)y = \sqrt{3}(L - x) for x[L2,L]x \in \left[\frac{L}{2}, L\right]

The hole HH is located on the base mirror BCBC at a distance ll from corner C(L,0)C(L,0), so its position is: H=(Ll,0),0<l<LH = (L - l, 0), \quad 0 < l < L


Analysis of Option A:

For θ=30\theta = 30^\circ, the ray enters through H(Ll,0)H(L-l, 0) into the interior of the triangle at an angle of 3030^\circ to the base BCBC (directed towards side ABAB).

The angle of the ray with the positive x-axis is 150150^\circ, so its direction vector is: u^=(cos30,sin30)=(32,12)\hat{u} = \left(-\cos 30^\circ, \sin 30^\circ\right) = \left(-\frac{\sqrt{3}}{2}, \frac{1}{2}\right)

The line equation of the ray is: y0=tan(150)(x(Ll))    x+3y=Lly - 0 = \tan(150^\circ)(x - (L-l)) \implies x + \sqrt{3}y = L - l

To find the intersection point P1P_1 with the left mirror ABAB (y=3xy = \sqrt{3}x): x+3(3x)=Ll    4x=Ll    x=Ll4x + \sqrt{3}(\sqrt{3}x) = L - l \implies 4x = L - l \implies x = \frac{L-l}{4} y=3(Ll)4y = \frac{\sqrt{3}(L-l)}{4}

Since 0<l<L0 < l < L, P1=(Ll4,3(Ll)4)P_1 = \left(\frac{L-l}{4}, \frac{\sqrt{3}(L-l)}{4}\right) lies strictly on the side ABAB.

Now, check the angle of incidence on side ABAB:

  • Slope of mirror ABAB: mAB=3=tan(60)m_{AB} = \sqrt{3} = \tan(60^\circ)
  • Slope of incoming ray: mray=13=tan(150)m_{\text{ray}} = -\frac{1}{\sqrt{3}} = \tan(150^\circ)

The product of their slopes is: mABmray=3(13)=1m_{AB} \cdot m_{\text{ray}} = \sqrt{3} \cdot \left(-\frac{1}{\sqrt{3}}\right) = -1

Since the product of the slopes is 1-1, the ray strikes mirror ABAB at normal incidence (9090^\circ to the mirror surface).

Upon normal incidence, the ray retraces its path completely back along the same line: x+3y=Llx + \sqrt{3}y = L - l It returns directly to (Ll,0)=H(L-l, 0) = H and exits through the hole after 11 reflection for any 0<l<L0 < l < L.

Thus, Option A is correct.


Analysis of Option B:

For l=L2l = \frac{L}{2}, the hole is located at the midpoint of the base: H=(L2,0)H = \left(\frac{L}{2}, 0\right)

Let a ray enter through HH at an angle θ=60\theta = 60^\circ to the base (directed towards side ABAB). Its direction vector inside the triangle is: u^1=(cos60,sin60)=(12,32)\hat{u}_1 = \left(-\cos 60^\circ, \sin 60^\circ\right) = \left(-\frac{1}{2}, \frac{\sqrt{3}}{2}\right)

The line equation of the incoming ray is: 3x+y=3L2\sqrt{3}x + y = \frac{\sqrt{3}L}{2}

  1. First Reflection (on side ABAB): Intersection of ray with side ABAB (y=3xy = \sqrt{3}x): 3x+3x=3L2    x1=L4,y1=3L4\sqrt{3}x + \sqrt{3}x = \frac{\sqrt{3}L}{2} \implies x_1 = \frac{L}{4}, \quad y_1 = \frac{\sqrt{3}L}{4} Point P1=(L4,3L4)P_1 = \left(\frac{L}{4}, \frac{\sqrt{3}L}{4}\right) is the midpoint of side ABAB. The reflected ray direction becomes horizontal to the right: u^2=(1,0)\hat{u}_2 = (1, 0)

  2. Second Reflection (on side ACAC): The horizontal ray y=3L4y = \frac{\sqrt{3}L}{4} intersects side ACAC (y=3(Lx)y = \sqrt{3}(L-x)) at: 3L4=3(Lx)    x2=3L4,y2=3L4\frac{\sqrt{3}L}{4} = \sqrt{3}(L-x) \implies x_2 = \frac{3L}{4}, \quad y_2 = \frac{\sqrt{3}L}{4} Point P2=(3L4,3L4)P_2 = \left(\frac{3L}{4}, \frac{\sqrt{3}L}{4}\right) is the midpoint of side ACAC. By the law of reflection, the reflected ray direction is directed downwards at 6060^\circ: u^3=(12,32)\hat{u}_3 = \left(-\frac{1}{2}, -\frac{\sqrt{3}}{2}\right)

  3. Return to the Hole: The ray travels along the line: y3L4=3(x3L4)y - \frac{\sqrt{3}L}{4} = \sqrt{3}\left(x - \frac{3L}{4}\right) Setting y=0y = 0 gives x=L2x = \frac{L}{2}, which is the exact location of the hole H(L2,0)H\left(\frac{L}{2}, 0\right).

Thus, the ray comes out after two reflections.

Therefore, Option B is correct.


Analysis of Options C and D:

Consider a ray entering at θ=60\theta = 60^\circ for any distance 0<l<L0 < l < L. The hole position is H(Ll,0)H(L-l, 0).

Tracing the trajectory step-by-step:

  1. Segment 1 (HP1H \to P_1): Starts at H(Ll,0)H(L-l,0), hits side ABAB at P1=(Ll2,3(Ll)2)P_1 = \left(\frac{L-l}{2}, \frac{\sqrt{3}(L-l)}{2}\right) \rightarrow 1st reflection.
  2. Segment 2 (P1P2P_1 \to P_2): Reflects horizontally to side ACAC, hitting at P2=(L+l2,3(Ll)2)P_2 = \left(\frac{L+l}{2}, \frac{\sqrt{3}(L-l)}{2}\right) \rightarrow 2nd reflection.
  3. Segment 3 (P2P3P_2 \to P_3): Reflects downwards at 6060^\circ to base BCBC, hitting at P3=(l,0)P_3 = (l, 0). Since lLll \neq L-l (for lL/2l \neq L/2), P3HP_3 \neq H, so it reflects off the bottom mirror \rightarrow 3rd reflection.
  4. Segment 4 (P3P4P_3 \to P_4): Reflects upwards at 6060^\circ to side ACAC, hitting at P4=(L+l2,3(Ll)2)P_4 = \left(\frac{L+l}{2}, \frac{\sqrt{3}(L-l)}{2}\right) \rightarrow 4th reflection.
  5. Segment 5 (P4P5P_4 \to P_5): Reflects horizontally to side ABAB, hitting at P5=(Ll2,3(Ll)2)P_5 = \left(\frac{L-l}{2}, \frac{\sqrt{3}(L-l)}{2}\right) \rightarrow 5th reflection.
  6. Segment 6 (P5P6P_5 \to P_6): Reflects downwards at 6060^\circ to base BCBC, hitting at P6=(Ll,0)=HP_6 = (L-l, 0) = H.

Since P6P_6 is the hole HH, the ray exits through the hole after traversing 6 path segments and undergoing 5 reflections.

  • For l=L3l = \frac{L}{3}, the ray will exit through the hole after 5 reflections. Thus, statement (C) claiming it will "NEVER come out" is incorrect.
  • Statement (D) claims the ray comes out "after six reflections", but it exits after five reflections. Thus, statement (D) is incorrect.

Conclusion:

The correct statements are A and B.