JEE Challenger
More from Waves

Observations in Resonance Air Column Experiment for Sound Speed

A student performed the experiment to measure the speed of sound in air using resonance air-column method. Two resonances in the air-column were obtained by lowering the water level. The resonance with the shorter air-column is the first resonance and that with the longer air-column is the second resonance. Then,

Options

A

the intensity of the sound heard at the first resonance was more than that at the second resonance

Correct
B

the prongs of the tuning fork were kept in a horizontal plane above the resonance tube

C

the amplitude of vibration of the ends of the prongs is typically around 1 cm1\text{ cm}

D

the length of the air-column at the first resonance was somewhat shorter than 1/4th of the wavelength of the sound in air

Correct

Topics & Concepts

Step-by-Step Solution

To determine the correct statements regarding the resonance air-column experiment:

  1. Option (A): Intensity of Sound
    At the first resonance, the length of the air column is shorter (l1≈λ4−el_1 \approx \frac{\lambda}{4} - e), while at the second resonance, the length is longer (l2≈3λ4−el_2 \approx \frac{3\lambda}{4} - e). For the longer air column, there is greater dissipation and attenuation of sound energy due to multiple reflections and visco-thermal damping along the length of the tube. Consequently, the standing wave formed in the shorter air column has higher amplitude, and the intensity of the sound heard at the first resonance is greater than that at the second resonance.
    Therefore, Option (A) is correct.

  2. Option (B): Orientation of the Tuning Fork
    To produce strong longitudinal sound waves directed into the resonance tube, the prongs of the tuning fork must vibrate in a vertical plane above the open end of the tube (so that the motion of the prongs effectively compresses and rarefies the air column along its axis). Holding them in a horizontal plane is incorrect.
    Therefore, Option (B) is incorrect.

  3. Option (C): Amplitude of Vibration of the Prongs
    The typical amplitude of vibration of a tuning fork prong used in acoustic experiments is very small, typically of the order of a fraction of a millimeter (less than 1 mm1\text{ mm}). An amplitude of 1 cm1\text{ cm} is extraordinarily large and physically unrealistic for a standard tuning fork.
    Therefore, Option (C) is incorrect.

  4. Option (D): Length of the Air-Column at First Resonance
    Taking into account the end correction e≈0.6re \approx 0.6r (where rr is the radius of the tube), the antinode forms slightly outside the open end. The condition for the first resonance is:
    l1+e=λ4  ⟹  l1=λ4−el_1 + e = \frac{\lambda}{4} \implies l_1 = \frac{\lambda}{4} - e
    Since e>0e > 0, the actual length of the air column l1l_1 is somewhat shorter than 14th\frac{1}{4}\text{th} of the wavelength λ\lambda.
    Therefore, Option (D) is correct.

Correct Answer: A, D