JEE Challenger
More from System of Particles and Rotational Motion

Maximum Velocity for Pure Rolling of Spring Attached Disk

Comprehension Passage

A uniform thin cylindrical disk of mass MM and radius RR is attached to two identical massless springs of spring constant kk which are fixed to the wall as shown in the figure. The springs are attached to the axle of the disk symmetrically on either side at a distance dd from its centre. The axle is massless and both the springs and the axle are in a horizontal plane. The unstretched length of each spring is LL. The disk is initially at its equilibrium position with its centre of mass (CM) at a distance LL from the wall. The disk rolls without slipping with velocity V⃗0=V0i^\vec{V}_0 = V_0 \hat{i}. The coefficient of friction is μ\mu.

Passage Diagram 0

The maximum value of V0V_0 for which the disk will roll without slipping is

Options

A

μgMk\mu g \sqrt{\frac{M}{k}}

B

μgM2k\mu g \sqrt{\frac{M}{2k}}

C

μg3Mk\mu g \sqrt{\frac{3M}{k}}

Correct
D

μg5M2k\mu g \sqrt{\frac{5M}{2k}}

Step-by-Step Solution

To find the maximum initial velocity V0V_0 for which the disk rolls without slipping, we analyze the equations of motion for the disk undergoing Simple Harmonic Motion (SHM).

1. Equations of Motion

Let xx be the displacement of the center of mass of the disk from its equilibrium position. Two springs, each of constant kk, are attached to the disk, giving a total spring force of −2kx-2kx.

Let fsf_s be the static friction force acting on the disk at the contact point in the direction of motion.

For the translational motion of the center of mass:
Ma=−2kx+fs— (1)M a = -2kx + f_s \quad \text{--- (1)}

For the rotational motion about the center of mass:
τ=−fsR=Iα\tau = -f_s R = I \alpha

Since the disk is a uniform thin cylinder, its moment of inertia is I=12MR2I = \frac{1}{2} M R^2. Substituting this gives:
−fsR=(12MR2)α  ⟹  α=−2fsMR-f_s R = \left(\frac{1}{2} M R^2\right) \alpha \implies \alpha = -\frac{2 f_s}{M R}

For pure rolling without slipping, the condition connecting linear acceleration aa and angular acceleration α\alpha is:
a=αRa = \alpha R

Substituting α\alpha:
a=−2fsM  ⟹  fs=−Ma2— (2)a = -\frac{2 f_s}{M} \implies f_s = -\frac{M a}{2} \quad \text{--- (2)}

2. Angular Frequency of SHM

Substitute fs=−Ma2f_s = -\frac{M a}{2} into equation (1):
Ma=−2kx−Ma2M a = -2kx - \frac{M a}{2}
32Ma=−2kx  ⟹  a=−(4k3M)x\frac{3}{2} M a = -2kx \implies a = -\left(\frac{4k}{3M}\right) x

This represents SHM of the form a=−ω2xa = -\omega^2 x, where the angular frequency ω\omega is:
ω=4k3M\omega = \sqrt{\frac{4k}{3M}}

3. Maximum Friction Force

From equation (2), the magnitude of the static friction force at a displacement xx is:
∣fs∣=M∣a∣2=M2(4k3M∣x∣)=2k3∣x∣|f_s| = \frac{M |a|}{2} = \frac{M}{2} \left(\frac{4k}{3M} |x|\right) = \frac{2k}{3} |x|

The friction force reaches its maximum magnitude when the displacement xx reaches the amplitude AA of the motion:
(fs)max⁡=2k3A(f_s)_{\max} = \frac{2k}{3} A

4. Condition for Rolling Without Slipping

To prevent slipping, the maximum friction force required must not exceed the maximum possible static friction force:
(fs)max⁡≤μN=μMg(f_s)_{\max} \le \mu N = \mu M g
2k3A≤μMg  ⟹  A≤3μMg2k\frac{2k}{3} A \le \mu M g \implies A \le \frac{3 \mu M g}{2k}

5. Maximum Initial Velocity V0V_0

At the equilibrium position (x=0x = 0), the speed of the disk is maximum and equals the amplitude times the angular frequency:
V0=ωA  ⟹  A=V0ω=V03M4kV_0 = \omega A \implies A = \frac{V_0}{\omega} = V_0 \sqrt{\frac{3M}{4k}}

Substituting AA into the condition for no slipping:
V03M4k≤3μMg2kV_0 \sqrt{\frac{3M}{4k}} \le \frac{3 \mu M g}{2k}

Solving for V0V_0:
V0≤3μMg2k4k3MV_0 \le \frac{3 \mu M g}{2k} \sqrt{\frac{4k}{3M}}
V0≤3μMg2k⋅23kMV_0 \le \frac{3 \mu M g}{2k} \cdot \frac{2}{\sqrt{3}} \sqrt{\frac{k}{M}}
V0≤μg3MkV_0 \le \mu g \sqrt{\frac{3M}{k}}

Thus, the maximum value of V0V_0 for which the disk will roll without slipping is:
(V0)max⁡=μg3Mk(V_0)_{\max} = \mu g \sqrt{\frac{3M}{k}}

Correct Answer: C