JEE Challenger
More from Thermodynamics

Match Transformations with Phase Change and Thermodynamic Properties

Match the transformations in column I with appropriate options in column II

Column IColumn II(A) CO2(s)→CO2(g)(p) phase transition(B) CaCO3(s)→CaO(s)+CO2(g)(q) allotropic change(C) 2 H∙→H2(g)(r) ΔH is positive(D) P(white, solid)→P(red, solid)(s) ΔS is positive(t) ΔS is negative\begin{array}{ll} \textbf{Column I} & \textbf{Column II} \\ \text{(A) } \text{CO}_2(\text{s}) \rightarrow \text{CO}_2(\text{g}) & \text{(p) phase transition} \\ \text{(B) } \text{CaCO}_3(\text{s}) \rightarrow \text{CaO}(\text{s}) + \text{CO}_2(\text{g}) & \text{(q) allotropic change} \\ \text{(C) } 2\text{ H}^\bullet \rightarrow \text{H}_2(\text{g}) & \text{(r) } \Delta H \text{ is positive} \\ \text{(D) } \text{P}_{(\text{white, solid})} \rightarrow \text{P}_{(\text{red, solid})} & \text{(s) } \Delta S \text{ is positive} \\ & \text{(t) } \Delta S \text{ is negative} \end{array}

Options

A

(A)→(P,R,S),  (B)→(R,S),  (C)→(T),  (D)→(P,Q,T)(\text{A}) \rightarrow (\text{P}, \text{R}, \text{S}),\; (\text{B}) \rightarrow (\text{R}, \text{S}),\; (\text{C}) \rightarrow (\text{T}),\; (\text{D}) \rightarrow (\text{P}, \text{Q}, \text{T})

Correct
B

(A)→(P,R),  (B)→(R,S),  (C)→(T),  (D)→(P,Q,T)(\text{A}) \rightarrow (\text{P}, \text{R}),\; (\text{B}) \rightarrow (\text{R}, \text{S}),\; (\text{C}) \rightarrow (\text{T}),\; (\text{D}) \rightarrow (\text{P}, \text{Q}, \text{T})

C

(A)→(P,R,S),  (B)→(R),  (C)→(T),  (D)→(Q,T)(\text{A}) \rightarrow (\text{P}, \text{R}, \text{S}),\; (\text{B}) \rightarrow (\text{R}),\; (\text{C}) \rightarrow (\text{T}),\; (\text{D}) \rightarrow (\text{Q}, \text{T})

D

(A)→(R,S),  (B)→(S),  (C)→(T),  (D)→(P,T)(\text{A}) \rightarrow (\text{R}, \text{S}),\; (\text{B}) \rightarrow (\text{S}),\; (\text{C}) \rightarrow (\text{T}),\; (\text{D}) \rightarrow (\text{P}, \text{T})

Step-by-Step Solution

To match the transformations in Column I with the appropriate thermodynamic and physical properties in Column II, we analyze each process systematically:


(A) CO2(s)→CO2(g)\text{CO}_2(\text{s}) \rightarrow \text{CO}_2(\text{g})

  1. Phase Transition:
    This transformation represents the sublimation of solid carbon dioxide (dry ice) directly into gaseous carbon dioxide without passing through the liquid phase. Since there is a change of state from solid to gas for a single chemical substance, it is a phase transition.
      ⟹  (p)\implies \textbf{(p)}

  2. Enthalpy Change (ΔH\Delta H):
    Sublimation requires the input of energy to overcome the intermolecular van der Waals forces holding the CO2\text{CO}_2 molecules in the crystal lattice. Thus, the process is endothermic:
    ΔHsub>0\Delta H_{\text{sub}} > 0
      ⟹  (r)\implies \textbf{(r)}

  3. Entropy Change (ΔS\Delta S):
    Gaseous molecules have vastly higher degrees of freedom and translational motion compared to the ordered, fixed arrangement in a crystal lattice. Therefore, the disorder of the system increases:
    ΔS>0\Delta S > 0
      ⟹  (s)\implies \textbf{(s)}

Hence, (A) matches with p, r, s.


(B) CaCO3(s)→CaO(s)+CO2(g)\text{CaCO}_3(\text{s}) \rightarrow \text{CaO}(\text{s}) + \text{CO}_2(\text{g})

  1. Enthalpy Change (ΔH\Delta H):
    The thermal decomposition of limestone (CaCO3\text{CaCO}_3) into quicklime (CaO\text{CaO}) and carbon dioxide gas is a well-known endothermic chemical reaction requiring high temperatures:
    ΔH>0\Delta H > 0
      ⟹  (r)\implies \textbf{(r)}

  2. Entropy Change (ΔS\Delta S):
    The reaction produces one mole of gas (CO2\text{CO}_2) from a purely solid reactant (Δng=1−0=+1\Delta n_g = 1 - 0 = +1). Since gases possess much higher molar entropy than solids, the entropy of the system increases significantly:
    ΔS>0\Delta S > 0
      ⟹  (s)\implies \textbf{(s)}

Hence, (B) matches with r, s.


(C) 2 H∙→H2(g)2\text{ H}^\bullet \rightarrow \text{H}_2(\text{g})

  1. Enthalpy Change (ΔH\Delta H):
    This process represents the combination of two free hydrogen radicals/atoms to form a stable covalent H−H\text{H}-\text{H} bond. Since bond formation releases energy, the process is exothermic:
    ΔH<0\Delta H < 0

  2. Entropy Change (ΔS\Delta S):
    Two independent gaseous radicals combine to form a single diatomic molecule (Δng=1−2=−1\Delta n_g = 1 - 2 = -1). The reduction in the number of free particles reduces the total degrees of translational freedom and randomness in the system:
    ΔS<0\Delta S < 0
      ⟹  (t)\implies \textbf{(t)}

Hence, (C) matches with t.


(D) P(white, solid)→P(red, solid)\text{P}_{(\text{white, solid})} \rightarrow \text{P}_{(\text{red, solid})}

  1. Phase Transition and Allotropic Change:

    • White phosphorus and red phosphorus are allotropes of elemental phosphorus. Hence, the transformation is an allotropic change.
        ⟹  (q)\implies \textbf{(q)}
    • An allotropic change between different solid forms of an element is categorized as a solid-to-solid phase transition.
        ⟹  (p)\implies \textbf{(p)}
  2. Enthalpy Change (ΔH\Delta H):
    White phosphorus consists of strained, discrete tetrahedral P4\text{P}_4 units, while red phosphorus exists as an interconnected, strain-relieved polymeric chain of P4\text{P}_4 units. Because red phosphorus is thermodynamically more stable than white phosphorus at standard conditions, the conversion is exothermic:
    ΔH<0\Delta H < 0

  3. Entropy Change (ΔS\Delta S):
    Due to the rigid, interconnected polymeric network of red phosphorus compared to the discrete molecular units of white phosphorus, red phosphorus has a more ordered structure with lower entropy (Sred∘<Swhite∘S^\circ_{\text{red}} < S^\circ_{\text{white}}). Consequently:
    ΔS<0\Delta S < 0
      ⟹  (t)\implies \textbf{(t)}

Hence, (D) matches with p, q, t.


Final Matching:

  • A →\rightarrow p, r, s
  • B →\rightarrow r, s
  • C →\rightarrow t
  • D →\rightarrow p, q, t