JEE Challenger
More from Electric Charges and Fields

Electric Flux Through Cube Faces with Enclosed Point Charges

Consider a cubical region of side length aa with its center located at the origin. It encloses three fixed point charges: −q-q at (0,−a/4,0)(0, -a/4, 0), +3q+3q at (0,0,0)(0, 0, 0), and −q-q at (0,+a/4,0)(0, +a/4, 0). Select the correct option(s).

Question Diagram 1

Options

A

The net electric flux through the plane x=+a/2x = +a/2 is equal to that through the plane x=−a/2x = -a/2.

Correct
B

The net electric flux crossing the plane y=+a/2y = +a/2 is greater than the flux crossing the plane y=−a/2y = -a/2.

C

The total electric flux passing through the whole cubical boundary is qε0\frac{q}{\varepsilon_0}.

Correct
D

The net electric flux crossing the plane z=+a/2z = +a/2 is equal to the net electric flux crossing the plane x=+a/2x = +a/2.

Correct

Step-by-Step Solution

To solve this problem, we analyze the charge distribution and apply Gauss's Law along with spatial symmetry arguments.

1. Total Electric Flux Through the Cube (Option C)

According to Gauss's Law, the total electric flux Φtotal\Phi_{\text{total}} passing through any closed surface is proportional to the total net charge enclosed within that surface: Φtotal=Qenclosedε0\Phi_{\text{total}} = \frac{Q_{\text{enclosed}}}{\varepsilon_0}

The cubical region of side length aa centered at the origin encloses three point charges:

  1. q1=−qq_1 = -q at (0,−a/4,0)(0, -a/4, 0)
  2. q2=+3qq_2 = +3q at (0,0,0)(0, 0, 0)
  3. q3=−qq_3 = -q at (0,+a/4,0)(0, +a/4, 0)

The net enclosed charge QenclosedQ_{\text{enclosed}} is: Qenclosed=q1+q2+q3=(−q)+(+3q)+(−q)=+qQ_{\text{enclosed}} = q_1 + q_2 + q_3 = (-q) + (+3q) + (-q) = +q

Therefore, the total flux through the cubical surface is: Φtotal=qε0\Phi_{\text{total}} = \frac{q}{\varepsilon_0}

Thus, Option C is correct.


2. Comparison of Flux through x=+a/2x = +a/2 and x=−a/2x = -a/2 (Option A)

All three charges lie on the yy-axis (x=0,z=0x = 0, z = 0).

Since the charge distribution is symmetric about the yy-zz plane (x=0x = 0), performing a reflection across x=0x = 0 (x→−xx \to -x) leaves the charge distribution completely unchanged.

By this mirror symmetry, the electric field lines exiting through the face at x=+a/2x = +a/2 are symmetric to those exiting through the face at x=−a/2x = -a/2. Thus, the net electric flux crossing the plane x=+a/2x = +a/2 is equal to that crossing the plane x=−a/2x = -a/2: Φx=+a/2=Φx=−a/2\Phi_{x = +a/2} = \Phi_{x = -a/2}

Thus, Option A is correct.


3. Comparison of Flux through y=+a/2y = +a/2 and y=−a/2y = -a/2 (Option B)

The charges are located at y=−a/4y = -a/4, y=0y = 0, and y=+a/4y = +a/4.

Notice that the charge distribution is symmetric under reflection across the xx-zz plane (y→−yy \to -y), because:

  • The charge at y=−a/4y = -a/4 is −q-q.
  • The charge at y=+a/4y = +a/4 is −q-q.
  • The charge at y=0y = 0 is +3q+3q.

Reflecting the system across y=0y = 0 swaps the two −q-q charges and leaves +3q+3q at the origin, resulting in the exact same charge configuration. Therefore, the net electric flux through the face y=+a/2y = +a/2 must be equal to the net electric flux through the face y=−a/2y = -a/2: Φy=+a/2=Φy=−a/2\Phi_{y = +a/2} = \Phi_{y = -a/2}

Since the flux through y=+a/2y = +a/2 is equal to (not greater than) the flux through y=−a/2y = -a/2, Option B is incorrect.


4. Comparison of Flux through z=+a/2z = +a/2 and x=+a/2x = +a/2 (Option D)

Since all three charges lie entirely along the yy-axis, the charge distribution possesses continuous rotational symmetry (cylindrical symmetry) about the yy-axis.

Rotating the system about the yy-axis by 90∘90^\circ maps the xx-axis onto the zz-axis. The square face located at x=+a/2x = +a/2 (defined by x=a/2,−a/2≤y≤a/2,−a/2≤z≤a/2x = a/2, -a/2 \le y \le a/2, -a/2 \le z \le a/2) maps perfectly onto the square face located at z=+a/2z = +a/2 (defined by z=a/2,−a/2≤x≤a/2,−a/2≤y≤a/2z = a/2, -a/2 \le x \le a/2, -a/2 \le y \le a/2).

Due to this axial symmetry about the yy-axis, the electric flux through the plane z=+a/2z = +a/2 is equal to the electric flux through the plane x=+a/2x = +a/2: Φz=+a/2=Φx=+a/2\Phi_{z = +a/2} = \Phi_{x = +a/2}

Thus, Option D is correct.


Conclusion

The correct options are A, C, and D.