JEE Challenger
More from Electric Charges and Fields

Electric Field Potential Magnetic Field and Moment of Rotating Charges

Six point charges, each of the same magnitude qq, are arranged in different manners as shown in Column II. In each case, a point M\text{M} and a line PQ\text{PQ} passing through M\text{M} are shown. Let EE be the electric field and VV be the electric potential at M\text{M} (potential at infinity is zero) due to the given charge distribution when it is at rest. Now, the whole system is set into rotation with a constant angular velocity about the line PQ\text{PQ}. Let BB be the magnetic field at M\text{M} and μ\mu be the magnetic moment of the system in this condition. Assume each rotating charge to be equivalent to a steady current.

Column I

(A) E=0E = 0

(B) V≠0V \neq 0

(C) B=0B = 0

(D) μ≠0\mu \neq 0

Column II

(p) Charges are at the corners of a regular hexagon. M\text{M} is at the centre of the hexagon. PQ\text{PQ} is perpendicular to the plane of the hexagon.

Diagram 0

(q) Charges are on a line perpendicular to PQ\text{PQ} at equal intervals. M\text{M} is the mid-point between the two innermost charges.

Diagram 1

(r) Charges are placed on two coplanar insulating rings at equal intervals. M\text{M} is the common centre of the rings. PQ\text{PQ} is perpendicular to the plane of the rings.

Diagram 2

(s) Charges are placed at the corners of a rectangle of sides aa and 2a2a and at the mid points of the longer sides. M\text{M} is at the centre of the rectangle. PQ\text{PQ} is parallel to the longer sides.

Diagram 3

(t) Charges are placed on two coplanar, identical insulating rings at equal intervals. M\text{M} is the mid-point between the centres of the rings. PQ\text{PQ} is perpendicular to the line joining the centres and coplanar to the rings.

Diagram 4

Options

A

(A) →\to p, r, s

Correct
B

(B) →\to r, s

Correct
C

(C) →\to p, q, t

Correct
D

(D) →\to r, s

Correct

Step-by-Step Solution

To find the correct match for each entry in Column I, we analyze each configuration given in Column II:


Analysis of Configurations in Column II:

  1. Configuration (p):
    • Charges and Geometry: Six charges arranged at the vertices of a regular hexagon. Three charges are +q+q forming an equilateral triangle, and the other three are −q-q forming another inverted equilateral triangle.
    • Electric Field (EE): The electric fields due to the three symmetric +q+q charges at the center M\text{M} cancel out to zero (E⃗+=0\vec{E}_+ = 0). Similarly, the electric fields due to the three −q-q charges cancel out (E⃗−=0\vec{E}_- = 0). Thus, the net electric field is:
      E=0E = 0
    • Electric Potential (VV): All charges are at an equal distance RR from the center M\text{M}. The sum of charges is ∑qi=3(+q)+3(−q)=0\sum q_i = 3(+q) + 3(-q) = 0. Therefore:
      V=14πε0R∑qi=0V = \frac{1}{4\pi\varepsilon_0 R} \sum q_i = 0
    • Magnetic Field (BB) and Magnetic Moment (μ\mu): The line PQ\text{PQ} is perpendicular to the plane of the hexagon and passes through M\text{M}. When rotated about PQ\text{PQ}, all charges move in circles of radius RR. The equivalent circular current due to the positive charges is I+=3(qω2π)I_+ = 3\left(\frac{q\omega}{2\pi}\right), and due to the negative charges is I−=−3(qω2π)I_- = -3\left(\frac{q\omega}{2\pi}\right). The net circulating current is zero:
      Inet=I++I−=0  ⟹  B=0andμ=0I_{\text{net}} = I_+ + I_- = 0 \implies B = 0 \quad \text{and} \quad \mu = 0
    • Matches: (p) satisfies E=0E = 0 and B=0B = 0.

  1. Configuration (q):
    • Charges and Geometry: Six charges are arranged symmetrically about M\text{M} along a line perpendicular to PQ\text{PQ}. At each symmetric distance rir_i from M\text{M}, there is a pair of opposite charges +q+q and −q-q.
    • Electric Field (EE): Since opposite charges lie on opposite sides of M\text{M}, their electric fields at the midpoint M\text{M} point in the same direction and reinforce each other:
      E≠0E \neq 0
    • Electric Potential (VV): At each distance rir_i, the pair contributes +q+q and −q-q, so their potentials cancel pairwise:
      V=∑kqiri=0V = \sum \frac{k q_i}{r_i} = 0
    • Magnetic Field (BB) and Magnetic Moment (μ\mu): During rotation about PQ\text{PQ}, each pair of charges at distance rir_i traces out the same circle of radius rir_i. The net charge on any circle is (+q)+(−q)=0(+q) + (-q) = 0, producing zero net circular current at each radius:
      B=0andμ=0B = 0 \quad \text{and} \quad \mu = 0
    • Matches: (q) satisfies B=0B = 0.

  1. Configuration (r):
    • Charges and Geometry: The charges are arranged symmetrically on two concentric coplanar rings with their common center at M\text{M}. The net charge of the system is non-zero (∑qi≠0\sum q_i \neq 0).
    • Electric Field (EE): By circular symmetry of the equal-interval charge distribution on each ring:
      E=0E = 0
    • Electric Potential (VV): Since the net charge is non-zero:
      V≠0V \neq 0
    • Magnetic Field (BB) and Magnetic Moment (μ\mu): The rotation axis PQ\text{PQ} passes perpendicularly through the common center M\text{M}. The rotation creates concentric circular currents with a non-zero net circulating charge:
      B≠0andμ≠0B \neq 0 \quad \text{and} \quad \mu \neq 0
    • Matches: (r) satisfies E=0E = 0, V≠0V \neq 0, and μ≠0\mu \neq 0.

  1. Configuration (s):
    • Charges and Geometry: Six charges are placed at the vertices and midpoints of the longer sides of a rectangle. The charge distribution is symmetric such that identical charges face each other across the center M\text{M}, and the net charge is non-zero.
    • Electric Field (EE): Equal charges are located diametrically opposite to each other across the center M\text{M}, so their electric field vectors cancel pairwise:
      E=0E = 0
    • Electric Potential (VV): Since the total charge is non-zero:
      V≠0V \neq 0
    • Magnetic Field (BB) and Magnetic Moment (μ\mu): Rotation about the line of symmetry PQ\text{PQ} produces non-zero equivalent current loops that generate a net magnetic field at M\text{M} and a net magnetic dipole moment:
      B≠0andμ≠0B \neq 0 \quad \text{and} \quad \mu \neq 0
    • Matches: (s) satisfies E=0E = 0, V≠0V \neq 0, and μ≠0\mu \neq 0.

  1. Configuration (t):
    • Charges and Geometry: Two identical rings carrying charges such that the net charge on the left ring is +3q+3q and on the right ring is −3q-3q. M\text{M} is the midpoint between the centers of the rings.
    • Electric Field (EE): The fields from the positively charged ring and negatively charged ring point in the same direction at M\text{M}:
      E≠0E \neq 0
    • Electric Potential (VV): By anti-symmetry about the perpendicular bisector line PQ\text{PQ}, the potential from the positive ring and negative ring cancel at every point on the plane of symmetry containing PQ\text{PQ}:
      V=0V = 0
    • Magnetic Field (BB) and Magnetic Moment (μ\mu): Due to the anti-symmetric arrangement of charges about the rotation axis PQ\text{PQ}, the magnetic field generated at M\text{M} and the total magnetic dipole moment cancel out:
      B=0andμ=0B = 0 \quad \text{and} \quad \mu = 0
    • Matches: (t) satisfies B=0B = 0.

Matching Summary:

  • (A) E=0E = 0 →\to p, r, s
  • (B) V≠0V \neq 0 →\to r, s
  • (C) B=0B = 0 →\to p, q, t
  • (D) μ≠0\mu \neq 0 →\to r, s