JEE Challenger
More from Laws of Motion

Matrix Match of Forces Energy and Torque in Mechanical Systems

Column II shows five systems in which two objects are labelled as X\mathrm{X} and Y\mathrm{Y}. Also in each case a point P\mathrm{P} is shown. Column I gives some statements about X\mathrm{X} and/or Y\mathrm{Y}. Match these statements to the appropriate system(s) from Column II.

Column I

(A) The force exerted by X\mathrm{X} on Y\mathrm{Y} has a magnitude MgMg.

(B) The gravitational potential energy of X\mathrm{X} is continuously increasing.

(C) Mechanical energy of the system X+Y\mathrm{X} + \mathrm{Y} is continuously decreasing.

(D) The torque of the weight of Y\mathrm{Y} about point P\mathrm{P} is zero.

Column II

(p) Block Y\mathrm{Y} of mass MM left on a fixed inclined plane X\mathrm{X}, slides on it with a constant velocity.

Diagram 0

(q) Two ring magnets Y\mathrm{Y} and Z\mathrm{Z}, each of mass MM, are kept in frictionless vertical plastic stand so that they repel each other. Y\mathrm{Y} rests on the base X\mathrm{X} and Z\mathrm{Z} hangs in air in equilibrium. P\mathrm{P} is the topmost point of the stand on the common axis of the two rings. The whole system is in a lift that is going up with a constant velocity.

Diagram 1

(r) A pulley Y\mathrm{Y} of mass m0m_0 is fixed to a table through a clamp X\mathrm{X}. A block of mass MM hangs from a string that goes over the pulley and is fixed at point P\mathrm{P} of the table. The whole system is kept in a lift that is going down with a constant velocity.

Diagram 2

(s) A sphere Y\mathrm{Y} of mass MM is put in a nonviscous liquid X\mathrm{X} kept in a container at rest. The sphere is released and it moves down in the liquid.

Diagram 3

(t) A sphere Y\mathrm{Y} of mass MM is falling with its terminal velocity in a viscous liquid X\mathrm{X} kept in a container.

Diagram 4

Options

A

(A) →\to (p), (t)

Correct
B

(B) →\to (q), (s), (t)

Correct
C

(C) →\to (p), (r), (t)

Correct
D

(D) →\to (q)

Correct

Step-by-Step Solution

To match each statement in Column I to the appropriate system(s) in Column II, we analyze each physical scenario in detail:


Analysis of Statement (A): The force exerted by X\mathrm{X} on Y\mathrm{Y} has a magnitude MgMg.

  1. System (p):

    • Block Y\mathrm{Y} of mass MM slides down the fixed inclined plane X\mathrm{X} at a constant velocity, meaning its acceleration is zero (a⃗Y=0⃗\vec{a}_{\mathrm{Y}} = \vec{0}).
    • From Newton's second law:
      ∑F⃗=F⃗X on Y+Mg⃗=0⃗  ⟹  F⃗X on Y=−Mg⃗\sum \vec{F} = \vec{F}_{\mathrm{X}\text{ on }\mathrm{Y}} + M\vec{g} = \vec{0} \implies \vec{F}_{\mathrm{X}\text{ on }\mathrm{Y}} = -M\vec{g}
    • The magnitude of the contact force exerted by X\mathrm{X} on Y\mathrm{Y} (the resultant of normal reaction and friction) is:
      ∣F⃗X on Y∣=Mg|\vec{F}_{\mathrm{X}\text{ on }\mathrm{Y}}| = Mg
    • Hence, (p) matches (A).
  2. System (q):

    • Magnet Z\mathrm{Z} of mass MM hangs in equilibrium above ring magnet Y\mathrm{Y}, so the magnetic repulsion between them is Fmag=MgF_{\text{mag}} = Mg.
    • Ring magnet Y\mathrm{Y} (mass MM) rests on the base X\mathrm{X} and moves with constant velocity. The forces acting on Y\mathrm{Y} in the vertical direction are its weight MgMg (downward), magnetic repulsion from Z\mathrm{Z} of magnitude MgMg (downward), and the normal force NN from X\mathrm{X} (upward):
      N−Mg−Fmag=0  ⟹  N=2MgN - Mg - F_{\text{mag}} = 0 \implies N = 2Mg
    • Thus, the force exerted by X\mathrm{X} on Y\mathrm{Y} is 2Mg≠Mg2Mg \neq Mg.
  3. System (r):

    • The pulley Y\mathrm{Y} of mass m0m_0 experiences the downward tension T=MgT = Mg from the hanging mass, a horizontal tension T=MgT = Mg from the anchored string, and its own weight m0gm_0 g. The net force exerted by clamp X\mathrm{X} on Y\mathrm{Y} balances these forces and does not have a magnitude of MgMg.
  4. System (s):

    • The sphere Y\mathrm{Y} accelerates downwards in the non-viscous liquid X\mathrm{X}, meaning the buoyant force (the force exerted by the liquid X\mathrm{X} on Y\mathrm{Y}) is strictly less than its weight: FB<MgF_B < Mg.
  5. System (t):

    • The sphere Y\mathrm{Y} falls with terminal velocity (constant velocity, a⃗=0⃗\vec{a} = \vec{0}) in the viscous liquid X\mathrm{X}.
    • By equilibrium of the sphere:
      F⃗net=F⃗X on Y+Mg⃗=0⃗  ⟹  ∣F⃗X on Y∣=Mg\vec{F}_{\text{net}} = \vec{F}_{\mathrm{X}\text{ on }\mathrm{Y}} + M\vec{g} = \vec{0} \implies |\vec{F}_{\mathrm{X}\text{ on }\mathrm{Y}}| = Mg
    • Hence, (t) matches (A).

Conclusion for (A): (A)→(p),(t)\mathbf{(A) \to (p), (t)}


Analysis of Statement (B): The gravitational potential energy of X\mathrm{X} is continuously increasing.

  1. System (p):

    • Inclined plane X\mathrm{X} is fixed; its position does not change, so its potential energy is constant.
  2. System (q):

    • The base X\mathrm{X} is inside a lift moving upwards with constant velocity. As its vertical coordinate zXz_{\mathrm{X}} increases with time, its gravitational potential energy UX=mXgzXU_{\mathrm{X}} = m_{\mathrm{X}} g z_{\mathrm{X}} continuously increases.
    • Hence, (q) matches (B).
  3. System (r):

    • The lift is moving downwards, so the height and gravitational potential energy of clamp X\mathrm{X} are continuously decreasing.
  4. System (s) and System (t):

    • In both cases, as the sphere Y\mathrm{Y} moves downwards through the liquid X\mathrm{X}, it displaces an equal volume of liquid upwards to occupy the space vacated above it.
    • Because liquid is transferred from lower levels to higher levels, the center of mass of the liquid X\mathrm{X} continuously shifts upwards.
    • Consequently, the gravitational potential energy of the liquid X\mathrm{X} is continuously increasing.
    • Hence, both (s) and (t) match (B).

Conclusion for (B): (B)→(q),(s),(t)\mathbf{(B) \to (q), (s), (t)}


Analysis of Statement (C): Mechanical energy of the system X+Y\mathrm{X} + \mathrm{Y} is continuously decreasing.

  1. System (p):

    • Block Y\mathrm{Y} moves down at constant velocity (constant kinetic energy), so its gravitational potential energy decreases. The inclined plane X\mathrm{X} is stationary. Mechanical energy is dissipated into thermal energy via friction between X\mathrm{X} and Y\mathrm{Y}.
    • Hence, the mechanical energy of X+Y\mathrm{X} + \mathrm{Y} is continuously decreasing.
    • Thus, (p) matches (C).
  2. System (q):

    • The lift moves upwards, increasing the potential energy of both X\mathrm{X} and Y\mathrm{Y} while keeping their kinetic energy constant. Thus, the mechanical energy is increasing.
  3. System (r):

    • The lift moves downwards at a constant velocity. The kinetic energies of both X\mathrm{X} and Y\mathrm{Y} remain constant, while their gravitational potential energies continuously decrease. Therefore, the total mechanical energy of X+Y\mathrm{X} + \mathrm{Y} is continuously decreasing.
    • Thus, (r) matches (C).
  4. System (s):

    • The liquid is non-viscous and no non-conservative forces act on the system. By conservation of mechanical energy, the mechanical energy of the system remains constant.
  5. System (t):

    • Due to the viscous drag (a non-conservative dissipative force), mechanical energy is continuously dissipated as heat as the sphere falls at terminal velocity.
    • Thus, (t) matches (C).

Conclusion for (C): (C)→(p),(r),(t)\mathbf{(C) \to (p), (r), (t)}


Analysis of Statement (D): The torque of the weight of Y\mathrm{Y} about point P\mathrm{P} is zero.

  • The torque of the weight about point P\mathrm{P} is given by:
    τ⃗P=r⃗P→cm×(Mg⃗)\vec{\tau}_{\mathrm{P}} = \vec{r}_{\mathrm{P} \to \mathrm{cm}} \times (M\vec{g})
  • This torque is zero if and only if the position vector of the center of mass of Y\mathrm{Y} relative to P\mathrm{P} is parallel to g⃗\vec{g}, meaning that point P\mathrm{P} lies on the vertical line passing through the center of mass of Y\mathrm{Y}.
  1. System (p): Point P\mathrm{P} is at the bottom corner of the incline and does not lie on the vertical line passing through the center of mass of block Y\mathrm{Y}. Thus, τ⃗P≠0⃗\vec{\tau}_{\mathrm{P}} \neq \vec{0}.
  2. System (q): P\mathrm{P} lies on the central vertical axis of the stand, which is also the axis of symmetry of the annular ring magnet Y\mathrm{Y}. The center of mass of Y\mathrm{Y} lies on this vertical axis directly below P\mathrm{P}. Hence, the line of action of the weight of Y\mathrm{Y} passes through P\mathrm{P}, yielding τ⃗P=0⃗\vec{\tau}_{\mathrm{P}} = \vec{0}.
    • Thus, (q) matches (D).
  3. Systems (r), (s), (t): In all these systems, point P\mathrm{P} is located away from the vertical line passing through the center of mass of Y\mathrm{Y}. Hence, the torque is non-zero.

Conclusion for (D): (D)→(q)\mathbf{(D) \to (q)}


Final Matching:

  • (A) →\to (p), (t)
  • (B) →\to (q), (s), (t)
  • (C) →\to (p), (r), (t)
  • (D) →\to (q)