JEE Challenger
More from Mechanical Properties of Fluids

Distance of Efflux Jet in an Accelerating Lift System

An individual inside an elevator holds a water container having a tiny hole near its lower end. When the elevator is stationary, the water jet exiting the hole hits the floor of the lift at a distance of 1.2 m1.2\text{ m} from the person. In the given lists, the motion state of the lift is described in List I, and the distance where the jet lands on the floor is listed in List II. Match List I with List II and select the correct option using the codes provided.

List IList IIP. Lift is accelerating vertically up.1. d=1.2 mQ. Lift is accelerating vertically down with a<g.2. d>1.2 mR. Lift is moving vertically up with constant speed.3. d<1.2 mS. Lift is falling freely.4. No water leaks out of the jar\begin{array}{ll} \textbf{List I} & \textbf{List II} \\ \text{P. Lift is accelerating vertically up.} & 1.\ d = 1.2\text{ m} \\ \text{Q. Lift is accelerating vertically down with } a < g. & 2.\ d > 1.2\text{ m} \\ \text{R. Lift is moving vertically up with constant speed.} & 3.\ d < 1.2\text{ m} \\ \text{S. Lift is falling freely.} & 4.\ \text{No water leaks out of the jar} \end{array}

Options

A

P-2, Q-3, R-2, S-4

B

P-2, Q-3, R-1, S-4

C

P-1, Q-1, R-1, S-4

Correct
D

P-2, Q-3, R-1, S-1

Step-by-Step Solution

To determine the distance dd where the water jet lands on the floor of the lift, we consider the motion in the non-inertial frame of reference of the lift.

1. General Formula for Efflux Jet Distance

Let:

  • HH be the height of the water column above the hole.
  • hh be the vertical distance from the hole to the floor of the lift.
  • geffg_{\text{eff}} be the effective acceleration due to gravity inside the lift's reference frame.

Speed of Efflux: Applying Bernoulli's principle in the reference frame of the lift, the velocity of the water jet coming out horizontally from the hole is given by Torricelli's Law: v=2geffHv = \sqrt{2 g_{\text{eff}} H}

Time of Flight: The vertical trajectory of the water jet inside the lift is governed by geffg_{\text{eff}}. The time tt required for the water stream to fall a vertical distance hh to reach the floor is: h=12gefft2  ⟹  t=2hgeffh = \frac{1}{2} g_{\text{eff}} t^2 \implies t = \sqrt{\frac{2h}{g_{\text{eff}}}}

Horizontal Distance (dd): The horizontal range dd of the jet on the floor of the lift is: d=v×t=2geffH×2hgeff=2Hhd = v \times t = \sqrt{2 g_{\text{eff}} H} \times \sqrt{\frac{2h}{g_{\text{eff}}}} = 2\sqrt{H h}

Notice that the effective acceleration due to gravity geffg_{\text{eff}} cancels out completely. Therefore, as long as geff>0g_{\text{eff}} > 0, the distance dd is independent of the acceleration of the lift and remains constant at d=1.2 md = 1.2\text{ m}.


2. Analysis of Individual Cases

  • P. Lift is accelerating vertically up: The effective gravity is geff=g+a>0g_{\text{eff}} = g + a > 0. Since dd is independent of geffg_{\text{eff}}, d=1.2 md = 1.2\text{ m}. P matches with 1.

  • Q. Lift is accelerating vertically down with a<ga < g: The effective gravity is geff=g−a>0g_{\text{eff}} = g - a > 0. Since dd is independent of geffg_{\text{eff}}, d=1.2 md = 1.2\text{ m}. Q matches with 1.

  • R. Lift is moving vertically up with constant speed (a=0a = 0): The effective gravity is geff=gg_{\text{eff}} = g. Therefore, d=1.2 md = 1.2\text{ m}. R matches with 1.

  • S. Lift is falling freely (a=ga = g): The effective gravity is geff=g−g=0g_{\text{eff}} = g - g = 0. In state of weightlessness, there is no hydrostatic pressure difference across the depth of the fluid, so no force pushes the water out. Thus, no water leaks out of the jar. S matches with 4.


Conclusion

The correct matching is: P-1, Q-1, R-1, S-4

Correct Option: C