JEE Challenger
More from Oscillations

Condition on Total Energy for Periodic Motion in Potential Well

Comprehension Passage

When a particle of mass mm moves on the xx-axis in a potential of the form V(x)=kx2V(x) = kx^2, it performs simple harmonic motion. The corresponding time period is proportional to mk\sqrt{\frac{m}{k}}, as can be seen easily using dimensional analysis. However, the motion of a particle can be periodic even when its potential energy increases on both sides of x=0x = 0 in a way different from kx2kx^2 and its total energy is such that the particle does not escape to infinity. Consider a particle of mass mm moving on the xx-axis. Its potential energy is V(x)=αx4V(x) = \alpha x^4 (α>0\alpha > 0) for ∣x∣|x| near the origin and becomes a constant equal to V0V_0 for ∣x∣≥X0|x| \ge X_0 (see figure).

Passage Diagram 0

If the total energy of the particle is EE, it will perform periodic motion only if

Official Notice: Marks Awarded to All

This question was dropped / full marks were awarded to all candidates in the official answer key by the exam conducting body due to an ambiguity or error in the question or options.

Options

A

E<0E < 0

B

E>0E > 0

C

V0>E>0V_0 > E > 0

D

E>V0E > V_0

Topics & Concepts

Step-by-Step Solution

To determine the condition on the total energy EE for the particle to perform periodic motion, we analyze the potential energy curve V(x)V(x):

  1. Minimum Potential Energy:
    Near the origin, the potential energy is given by:
    V(x)=αx4(α>0)V(x) = \alpha x^4 \quad (\alpha > 0)
    The minimum potential energy occurs at x=0x = 0:
    Vmin=V(0)=0V_{\text{min}} = V(0) = 0
    The kinetic energy of the particle is given by:
    K=E−V(x)≥0  ⟹  E≥V(x)K = E - V(x) \ge 0 \implies E \ge V(x)
    For the particle to move (i.e., not remain permanently at rest at x=0x = 0), its total energy must be strictly greater than the minimum potential energy:
    E>0E > 0

  2. Bound State Condition (Confinement):
    For ∣x∣≥X0|x| \ge X_0, the potential energy becomes a constant value V0V_0.

    • If E≥V0E \ge V_0, the particle has sufficient energy to overcome the potential well and escape to infinity (∣x∣→∞|x| \to \infty). Such motion is unbounded and therefore non-periodic.
    • If E<V0E < V_0, the particle encounters classical turning points at x=±xtx = \pm x_t (where ∣xt∣<X0|x_t| < X_0 and V(±xt)=EV(\pm x_t) = E). The particle is trapped within the potential well, oscillating back and forth between −xt-x_t and +xt+x_t, which constitutes periodic motion.

Combining both conditions:

  • For periodic motion to occur, the total energy must satisfy:
    0<E<V00 < E < V_0
    This corresponds directly to Option C.

  • Since the question asks "will perform periodic motion only if", it specifies a necessary condition (A  ⟹  BA \implies B). Since 0<E<V00 < E < V_0 implies E>0E > 0, the condition E>0E > 0 is also a strictly necessary condition, making Option B valid as well.

Therefore, the correct options are B and C.