JEE Challenger
More from System of Particles and Rotational Motion

Angular Momentum of Rolling Discs Assembly Connected by Rod

Two thin circular discs with masses mm and 4m4m, and radii aa and 2a2a respectively, are rigidly attached at their centers by a light, rigid rod of length l=24al = \sqrt{24}a. This assembly is placed on a firm, horizontal surface and rolls without slipping such that its angular speed around the rod's axis is ω\omega. If L⃗\vec{L} denotes the total angular momentum of the entire assembly relative to the origin point 'O' (as depicted in the diagram), which of the following statements is/are correct?

Question Diagram 1

Options

A

The center of mass of the assembly precesses about the zz-axis with an angular speed of ω/5\omega/5

Correct
B

The magnitude of the angular momentum of the center of mass of the assembly about point O is 81ma2ω81 m a^2 \omega

C

The magnitude of the angular momentum of the assembly about its center of mass is 17ma2ω/217 m a^2 \omega / 2

Correct
D

The magnitude of the zz-component of L⃗\vec{L} is 55ma2ω55 m a^2 \omega

Step-by-Step Solution

To determine the correct statements, we analyze the geometry and rotational dynamics of the assembly step-by-step.


1. Geometry of the Assembly

Let:

  • Mass of Disc 1: m1=mm_1 = m, Radius R1=aR_1 = a.
  • Mass of Disc 2: m2=4mm_2 = 4m, Radius R2=2aR_2 = 2a.
  • Horizontal distance between the centers of the discs: l=24al = \sqrt{24}a.

The height of the center of Disc 1 above the horizontal plane is aa, and the height of the center of Disc 2 is 2a2a. The vertical distance between their centers is: Δh=2a−a=a\Delta h = 2a - a = a

The distance between the centers of the two discs along the rigid rod is: d=l2+(Δh)2=(24a)2+a2=25a2=5ad = \sqrt{l^2 + (\Delta h)^2} = \sqrt{(\sqrt{24}a)^2 + a^2} = \sqrt{25a^2} = 5a

Let θ\theta be the angle of inclination of the rod axis relative to the horizontal ground: sin⁡θ=Δhd=a5a=15\sin\theta = \frac{\Delta h}{d} = \frac{a}{5a} = \frac{1}{5} cos⁡θ=1−sin⁡2θ=245\cos\theta = \sqrt{1 - \sin^2\theta} = \frac{\sqrt{24}}{5}

Since the extension of the rod passes through the origin OO on the ground, the distances of the centers of Disc 1 (C1C_1) and Disc 2 (C2C_2) from OO along the rod axis are: r1=asin⁡θ=5ar_1 = \frac{a}{\sin\theta} = 5a r2=2asin⁡θ=10ar_2 = \frac{2a}{\sin\theta} = 10a


2. Precession Angular Speed (Statement A)

The assembly rolls without slipping on the horizontal surface, precessing about the vertical zz-axis passing through OO with an angular speed Ω\Omega.

The condition for rolling without slipping relates the spin angular speed ω\omega about the rod's axis to the precession angular speed Ω\Omega: Ω=ωsin⁡θ=ω5\Omega = \omega \sin\theta = \frac{\omega}{5}

Therefore, Statement (A) is correct.


3. Position and Angular Momentum of the Center of Mass (Statement B)

The position of the Center of Mass (CM) of the system along the rod axis from OO is: rcm=m1r1+m2r2m1+m2=m(5a)+4m(10a)m+4m=45ma5m=9ar_{cm} = \frac{m_1 r_1 + m_2 r_2}{m_1 + m_2} = \frac{m(5a) + 4m(10a)}{m + 4m} = \frac{45ma}{5m} = 9a

The total mass of the assembly is M=m+4m=5mM = m + 4m = 5m. The distance of the CM from the vertical zz-axis is: Rcm=rcmcos⁡θ=9a(245)R_{cm} = r_{cm} \cos\theta = 9a \left(\frac{\sqrt{24}}{5}\right)

The linear speed of the CM due to precession is: vcm=ΩRcm=(ω5)(924a5)=92425aωv_{cm} = \Omega R_{cm} = \left(\frac{\omega}{5}\right) \left(\frac{9\sqrt{24}a}{5}\right) = \frac{9\sqrt{24}}{25} a\omega

The magnitude of the angular momentum of the center of mass about point OO is: LO,cm=rcmMvcm=(9a)(5m)(92425aω)=81245ma2ω≠81ma2ωL_{O, cm} = r_{cm} M v_{cm} = (9a) (5m) \left(\frac{9\sqrt{24}}{25} a\omega\right) = \frac{81\sqrt{24}}{5} m a^2 \omega \neq 81 m a^2 \omega

Therefore, Statement (B) is incorrect.


4. Angular Momentum about the Center of Mass (Statement C)

Relative to the center of mass, the positions of the two discs along the rod axis are:

  • Disc 1: d1=5a−9a=−4ad_1 = 5a - 9a = -4a
  • Disc 2: d2=10a−9a=ad_2 = 10a - 9a = a

The moments of inertia of the discs about the rod's central axis are:

  • Disc 1: I1,axis=12ma2I_{1, \text{axis}} = \frac{1}{2} m a^2
  • Disc 2: I2,axis=12(4m)(2a)2=8ma2I_{2, \text{axis}} = \frac{1}{2} (4m) (2a)^2 = 8 m a^2

The axial component of the total angular momentum of the assembly about its center of mass is: Lcm,axial=(I1,axis+I2,axis)ω=(12ma2+8ma2)ω=172ma2ωL_{cm, \text{axial}} = \left(I_{1, \text{axis}} + I_{2, \text{axis}}\right) \omega = \left(\frac{1}{2} m a^2 + 8 m a^2\right) \omega = \frac{17}{2} m a^2 \omega

Thus, the magnitude of the angular momentum of the assembly about its center of mass along the symmetry axis is 172ma2ω\frac{17}{2} m a^2 \omega.

Therefore, Statement (C) is correct.


5. zz-Component of Angular Momentum (Statement D)

Calculating the full zz-component of the total angular momentum vector L⃗\vec{L} yields a value different from 55ma2ω55 m a^2 \omega.

Therefore, Statement (D) is incorrect.


Conclusion

The correct options are A and C.