JEE Challenger
More from Thermal Properties of Matter

Thermal Conductivity and Heat Flow in Composite Slabs

A composite block is made of slabs A, B, C, D and E of different thermal conductivities (given in terms of a constant K) and sizes (given in terms of length, L) as shown in the figure. All slabs are of same width. Heat ‘Q’ flows only from left to right through the blocks. Then in steady state

Diagram 0

Options

A

heat flow through A and E slabs are same.

Correct
B

heat flow through slab E is maximum.

C

temperature difference across slab E is smallest.

Correct
D

heat flow through C = heat flow through B + heat flow through D.

Correct

Step-by-Step Solution

To analyze the heat flow and temperature distribution across the composite block in the steady state, we can use the concept of thermal resistance, which is given by:
R=LKAR = \frac{L}{K A}
where LL is the length of the slab along the direction of heat flow, KK is the thermal conductivity, and AA is the cross-sectional area perpendicular to the heat flow. Let ww be the width of all the slabs (perpendicular to the plane of the diagram).


1. Geometrical and Thermal Parameters of Each Slab

From the given figure:

  • Slab A:

    • Length LA=1L−0=LL_A = 1L - 0 = L
    • Height hA=4L−0=4L  ⟹  AA=4L⋅wh_A = 4L - 0 = 4L \implies A_A = 4L \cdot w
    • Conductivity KA=2KK_A = 2K
    • Thermal Resistance:
      RA=L(2K)(4Lw)=18KwR_A = \frac{L}{(2K)(4L w)} = \frac{1}{8 Kw}
  • Slab B:

    • Length LB=5L−1L=4LL_B = 5L - 1L = 4L
    • Height hB=1L−0=1L  ⟹  AB=1L⋅wh_B = 1L - 0 = 1L \implies A_B = 1L \cdot w
    • Conductivity KB=3KK_B = 3K
    • Thermal Resistance:
      RB=4L(3K)(1Lw)=43KwR_B = \frac{4L}{(3K)(1L w)} = \frac{4}{3 Kw}
  • Slab C:

    • Length LC=5L−1L=4LL_C = 5L - 1L = 4L
    • Height hC=3L−1L=2L  ⟹  AC=2L⋅wh_C = 3L - 1L = 2L \implies A_C = 2L \cdot w
    • Conductivity KC=4KK_C = 4K
    • Thermal Resistance:
      RC=4L(4K)(2Lw)=12KwR_C = \frac{4L}{(4K)(2L w)} = \frac{1}{2 Kw}
  • Slab D:

    • Length LD=5L−1L=4LL_D = 5L - 1L = 4L
    • Height hD=4L−3L=1L  ⟹  AD=1L⋅wh_D = 4L - 3L = 1L \implies A_D = 1L \cdot w
    • Conductivity KD=5KK_D = 5K
    • Thermal Resistance:
      RD=4L(5K)(1Lw)=45KwR_D = \frac{4L}{(5K)(1L w)} = \frac{4}{5 Kw}
  • Slab E:

    • Length LE=6L−5L=LL_E = 6L - 5L = L
    • Height hE=4L−0=4L  ⟹  AE=4L⋅wh_E = 4L - 0 = 4L \implies A_E = 4L \cdot w
    • Conductivity KE=6KK_E = 6K
    • Thermal Resistance:
      RE=L(6K)(4Lw)=124KwR_E = \frac{L}{(6K)(4L w)} = \frac{1}{24 Kw}

2. Evaluation of Options

Analysis of Option (A):

Slab A, the combination of slabs (B, C, D), and slab E are connected in series along the heat flow path.
In a series arrangement, the total rate of heat flow through each section must be equal to the total heat current HH:
HA=HBCD=HE=HH_A = H_{BCD} = H_E = H
Hence, the heat flow through slab A and slab E is the same (HA=HEH_A = H_E).

  • Option (A) is CORRECT.

Analysis of Option (C):

Let HH be the total heat flow rate through the block.

  • Temperature difference across slab A:
    ΔTA=H⋅RA=H8Kw\Delta T_A = H \cdot R_A = \frac{H}{8 Kw}

  • Equivalent resistance RBCDR_{BCD} of the parallel combination of slabs B, C, and D:
    1RBCD=1RB+1RC+1RD=3Kw4+2Kw+5Kw4=4Kw\frac{1}{R_{BCD}} = \frac{1}{R_B} + \frac{1}{R_C} + \frac{1}{R_D} = \frac{3 Kw}{4} + 2 Kw + \frac{5 Kw}{4} = 4 Kw
    RBCD=14KwR_{BCD} = \frac{1}{4 Kw}
    Thus, the temperature difference across the parallel section (BCD) is:
    ΔTBCD=H⋅RBCD=H4Kw\Delta T_{BCD} = H \cdot R_{BCD} = \frac{H}{4 Kw}

  • Temperature difference across slab E:
    ΔTE=H⋅RE=H24Kw\Delta T_E = H \cdot R_E = \frac{H}{24 Kw}

Comparing the temperature differences:
ΔTE=13ΔTA=16ΔTBCD\Delta T_E = \frac{1}{3} \Delta T_A = \frac{1}{6} \Delta T_{BCD}
Therefore, the temperature difference across slab E is the smallest.

  • Option (C) is CORRECT.

Analysis of Option (D):

Since slabs B, C, and D are connected in parallel, they experience the same temperature difference ΔTBCD\Delta T_{BCD}. The heat flow through each individual slab is:
HB=ΔTBCDRB=ΔTBCD⋅(3Kw4)H_B = \frac{\Delta T_{BCD}}{R_B} = \Delta T_{BCD} \cdot \left(\frac{3 Kw}{4}\right)
HC=ΔTBCDRC=ΔTBCD⋅(2Kw)=ΔTBCD⋅(8Kw4)H_C = \frac{\Delta T_{BCD}}{R_C} = \Delta T_{BCD} \cdot \left(2 Kw\right) = \Delta T_{BCD} \cdot \left(\frac{8 Kw}{4}\right)
HD=ΔTBCDRD=ΔTBCD⋅(5Kw4)H_D = \frac{\Delta T_{BCD}}{R_D} = \Delta T_{BCD} \cdot \left(\frac{5 Kw}{4}\right)

Adding the heat flows through slab B and slab D:
HB+HD=ΔTBCD⋅(3Kw4+5Kw4)=ΔTBCD⋅(2Kw)=HCH_B + H_D = \Delta T_{BCD} \cdot \left( \frac{3 Kw}{4} + \frac{5 Kw}{4} \right) = \Delta T_{BCD} \cdot (2 Kw) = H_C
Hence, heat flow through C = heat flow through B + heat flow through D.

  • Option (D) is CORRECT.

Conclusion

The correct options are A, C, and D.