JEE Challenger
More from Magnetism and Matter

Resistance Variation of Superconductor in Magnetic Fields

Comprehension Passage

Electrical resistance of certain materials, known as superconductors, changes abruptly from a nonzero value to zero as their temperature is lowered below a critical temperature Tc(0)T_c(0). An interesting property of superconductors is that their critical temperature becomes smaller than Tc(0)T_c(0) if they are placed in a magnetic field, i.e., the critical temperature Tc(B)T_c(B) is a function of the magnetic field strength BB. The dependence of Tc(B)T_c(B) on BB is shown in the figure.

Passage Diagram 0

In the graphs below, the resistance R of a superconductor is shown as a function of its temperature T for two different magnetic fields B1B_1 (solid line) and B2B_2 (dashed line). If B2B_2 is larger than B1B_1, which of the following graphs shows the correct variation of R with T in these fields ?

Options

A
Option A Diagram 1
Correct
B
Option B Diagram 1
C
Option C Diagram 1
D
Option D Diagram 1

Step-by-Step Solution

Based on the provided passage and principles of superconductivity:

  1. Dependence of Critical Temperature on Magnetic Field:
    The critical temperature Tc(B)T_c(B) of a superconductor decreases as the applied magnetic field strength BB increases.
    Mathematically, if B2>B1B_2 > B_1, then:
    Tc(B2)<Tc(B1)T_c(B_2) < T_c(B_1)

  2. Resistance as a Function of Temperature:
    A material behaves as a superconductor (having zero electrical resistance, R=0R = 0) when its temperature TT is strictly less than its critical temperature Tc(B)T_c(B) for a given magnetic field BB:

    • For magnetic field B1B_1: R=0R = 0 for T≤Tc(B1)T \le T_c(B_1), and R>0R > 0 for T>Tc(B1)T > T_c(B_1).
    • For magnetic field B2B_2: R=0R = 0 for T≤Tc(B2)T \le T_c(B_2), and R>0R > 0 for T>Tc(B2)T > T_c(B_2).
  3. Comparison of Transition Points:
    Since B2>B1B_2 > B_1, the critical temperature Tc(B2)T_c(B_2) for field B2B_2 (dashed line) must lie to the left of Tc(B1)T_c(B_1) for field B1B_1 (solid line) on the temperature (TT) axis.

  4. Evaluating the Options:

    • Graph A: Shows the abrupt drop in resistance for the dashed line (B2B_2) occurring at a lower temperature than that for the solid line (B1B_1), i.e., Tc(B2)<Tc(B1)T_c(B_2) < T_c(B_1).
    • Graph C: Incorrectly shows Tc(B1)<Tc(B2)T_c(B_1) < T_c(B_2).
    • Graphs B and D: Incorrectly represent the normal state resistance and transition behavior.

Therefore, the correct variation of RR with TT is given by option A.