JEE Challenger
More from Moving Charges and Magnetism

Motion of Charged Particle in Transverse Magnetic Field Region

A particle of mass mm and charge qq, moving with velocity VV enters Region II normal to the boundary as shown in the figure. Region II has a uniform magnetic field BB perpendicular to the plane of the paper. The length of the Region II is ℓ\ell. Choose the correct choice(s).

Diagram 0

Options

A

The particle enters Region III only if its velocity V>qℓBmV > \frac{q \ell B}{m}

Correct
B

The particle enters Region III only if its velocity V<qℓBmV < \frac{q \ell B}{m}

C

Path length of the particle in Region II is maximum when velocity V=qℓBmV = \frac{q \ell B}{m}

Correct
D

Time spent in Region II is same for any velocity VV as long as the particle returns to Region I

Correct

Step-by-Step Solution

To determine the correct options, let us analyze the motion of the charged particle in Region II step by step.

1. Trajectory and Radius of Curvature

The particle of mass mm and charge qq enters Region II at a right angle to the boundary with velocity V⃗=Vi^\vec{V} = V\hat{i}.
The magnetic field in Region II is uniform and directed into the plane of the paper, B⃗=−Bk^\vec{B} = -B\hat{k}.

The magnetic Lorentz force acting on the particle is:
F⃗=q(V⃗×B⃗)=q(Vi^×(−Bk^))=qVBj^\vec{F} = q(\vec{V} \times \vec{B}) = q(V\hat{i} \times (-B\hat{k})) = qVB\hat{j}

This force provides the necessary centripetal acceleration, causing the particle to move along a circular path in the plane of the paper. The radius of this circular path is:
R=mVqBR = \frac{mV}{qB}

The center of this circular arc is located at (0,R)(0, R) in the Cartesian coordinate system where the entry point is (0,0)(0,0). The equation of the path is:
x2+(y−R)2=R2  ⟹  x=R2−(y−R)2x^2 + (y - R)^2 = R^2 \implies x = \sqrt{R^2 - (y - R)^2}

The maximum displacement along the xx-direction (perpendicular to the boundary) is:
xmax⁡=Rx_{\max} = R


2. Condition to Enter Region III (Options A and B)

The width of Region II is ℓ\ell.

  • If R≤ℓR \le \ell, the particle does not reach the right boundary x=ℓx = \ell. It completes a semicircle and exits back into Region I through the boundary x=0x = 0.
  • If R>ℓR > \ell, the particle reaches the boundary x=ℓx = \ell and enters Region III.

Therefore, the particle enters Region III if and only if:
R>ℓ  ⟹  mVqB>ℓ  ⟹  V>qℓBmR > \ell \implies \frac{mV}{qB} > \ell \implies V > \frac{q\ell B}{m}

Hence, Option (A) is correct and Option (B) is incorrect.


3. Path Length in Region II (Option C)

Let ss denote the path length of the particle inside Region II:

  1. For V≤qℓBmV \le \frac{q\ell B}{m} (R≤ℓR \le \ell):
    The particle describes a semicircle in Region II before exiting back to Region I. The path length is:
    s=πR=πmVqBs = \pi R = \frac{\pi mV}{qB}
    As VV increases from 00 to qℓBm\frac{q\ell B}{m}, the path length ss increases linearly from 00 to a maximum value of:
    s=πℓs = \pi \ell

  2. For V>qℓBmV > \frac{q\ell B}{m} (R>ℓR > \ell):
    The particle hits the boundary x=ℓx = \ell and enters Region III. The angle θ\theta subtended by the arc at the center of curvature is given by:
    sin⁡θ=ℓR\sin\theta = \frac{\ell}{R}
    The path length in Region II is:
    s=Rθ=Rarcsin⁡(ℓR)s = R\theta = R \arcsin\left(\frac{\ell}{R}\right)
    Letting u=ℓR∈(0,1)u = \frac{\ell}{R} \in (0, 1), we can write:
    s=ℓ(arcsin⁡uu)s = \ell \left(\frac{\arcsin u}{u}\right)
    Since the function f(u)=arcsin⁡uuf(u) = \frac{\arcsin u}{u} is strictly increasing for u∈(0,1)u \in (0, 1), its supremum occurs as u→1−u \to 1^- (i.e., as R→ℓ+R \to \ell^+):
    lim⁡u→1−s=ℓ⋅π2=πℓ2\lim_{u \to 1^-} s = \ell \cdot \frac{\pi}{2} = \frac{\pi \ell}{2}
    As V→∞V \to \infty (R→∞R \to \infty, u→0+u \to 0^+), s→ℓs \to \ell. Thus, for V>qℓBmV > \frac{q\ell B}{m}, the path length lies in the range:
    ℓ<s<πℓ2\ell < s < \frac{\pi\ell}{2}

Comparing both cases, the absolute maximum path length inside Region II occurs at V=qℓBmV = \frac{q\ell B}{m} with a value of smax⁡=πℓs_{\max} = \pi \ell.

Hence, Option (C) is correct.


4. Time Spent in Region II (Option D)

As long as the particle returns to Region I, it must complete a semicircle of angular displacement Δθ=π\Delta \theta = \pi.

The time spent inside Region II is equal to half the time period of circular motion:
t=T2=12(2πmqB)=πmqBt = \frac{T}{2} = \frac{1}{2}\left(\frac{2\pi m}{qB}\right) = \frac{\pi m}{qB}

Since this time depends only on the mass mm, charge qq, and magnetic field BB, it is entirely independent of the velocity VV.

Hence, Option (D) is correct.


Conclusion

The correct choices are (A), (C), and (D).