JEE Challenger
More from States of Matter

Match Gas Conditions with Properties and Thermodynamic Laws

Match gases under specified conditions listed in Column I with their properties/laws in Column II. Indicate your answer by darkening the appropriate bubbles of the 4×44 \times 4 matrix given in the ORS.

Column IColumn II(A) hydrogen gas (P=200 atm,T=273 K)(p) compressibility factor ≠1(B) hydrogen gas (P∼0,T=273 K)(q) attractive forces are dominant(C) CO2 (P=1 atm,T=273 K)(r) PV=nRT(D) real gas with very large molar volume(s) P(V−nb)=nRT\begin{array}{ll}\text{Column I} & \text{Column II} \\ (A)\text{ hydrogen gas } (P = 200\text{ atm}, T = 273\text{ K}) & (p)\text{ compressibility factor } \neq 1 \\ (B)\text{ hydrogen gas } (P \sim 0, T = 273\text{ K}) & (q)\text{ attractive forces are dominant} \\ (C)\text{ CO}_2\text{ } (P = 1\text{ atm}, T = 273\text{ K}) & (r)\text{ } PV = nRT \\ (D)\text{ real gas with very large molar volume} & (s)\text{ } P(V-nb) = nRT\end{array}

Options

A

(A)→(P),  (B)→(R,S),  (C)→(P,Q),  (D)→(R)(\text{A}) \rightarrow (\text{P}),\; (\text{B}) \rightarrow (\text{R}, \text{S}),\; (\text{C}) \rightarrow (\text{P}, \text{Q}),\; (\text{D}) \rightarrow (\text{R})

B

(A)→(P,S),  (B)→(R),  (C)→(Q),  (D)→(P,R)(\text{A}) \rightarrow (\text{P}, \text{S}),\; (\text{B}) \rightarrow (\text{R}),\; (\text{C}) \rightarrow (\text{Q}),\; (\text{D}) \rightarrow (\text{P}, \text{R})

C

(A)→(P,S),  (B)→(R),  (C)→(P,Q),  (D)→(R)(\text{A}) \rightarrow (\text{P}, \text{S}),\; (\text{B}) \rightarrow (\text{R}),\; (\text{C}) \rightarrow (\text{P}, \text{Q}),\; (\text{D}) \rightarrow (\text{R})

Correct
D

(A)→(S),  (B)→(R),  (C)→(P,Q),  (D)→(R)(\text{A}) \rightarrow (\text{S}),\; (\text{B}) \rightarrow (\text{R}),\; (\text{C}) \rightarrow (\text{P}, \text{Q}),\; (\text{D}) \rightarrow (\text{R})

Step-by-Step Solution

To match each condition in Column I with the corresponding properties/laws in Column II, we analyze the behavior of gases using the van der Waals equation of state:

(P+an2V2)(V−nb)=nRT\left(P + \frac{an^2}{V^2}\right)(V - nb) = nRT

where aa is the measure of intermolecular attractive forces and bb accounts for the finite size of the gas molecules. The compressibility factor is defined as Z=PVnRTZ = \frac{PV}{nRT}.


(A) Hydrogen gas (P=200 atm,T=273 KP = 200\text{ atm}, T = 273\text{ K})

  1. Hydrogen (H2\text{H}_2) has an extremely low polarizability, making intermolecular attractive forces negligible (a≈0a \approx 0) at 273 K273\text{ K}.
  2. At high pressure (P=200 atmP = 200\text{ atm}), the molar volume V/nV/n is small, so the molecular volume term nbnb cannot be neglected compared to VV.
  3. Substituting a≈0a \approx 0 into the van der Waals equation:
    P(V−nb)=nRTP(V - nb) = nRT
  4. Rearranging for the compressibility factor ZZ:
    PV−nPb=nRT  ⟹  Z=PVnRT=1+PbRT>1  ⟹  Z≠1PV - nPb = nRT \implies Z = \frac{PV}{nRT} = 1 + \frac{Pb}{RT} > 1 \implies Z \neq 1

Thus, (A) matches with (p) and (s).


(B) Hydrogen gas (P∼0,T=273 KP \sim 0, T = 273\text{ K})

  1. As the pressure approaches zero (P∼0P \sim 0), the molar volume becomes extremely large (V→∞V \to \infty).
  2. Under these conditions, both intermolecular forces (an2V2≈0\frac{an^2}{V^2} \approx 0) and the co-volume term (nb≪Vnb \ll V) become completely negligible.
  3. The equation reduces to the ideal gas law:
    PV=nRTPV = nRT
  4. Here, Z=1Z = 1.

Thus, (B) matches with (r).


(C) CO2\text{CO}_2 (P=1 atm,T=273 KP = 1\text{ atm}, T = 273\text{ K})

  1. For carbon dioxide (CO2\text{CO}_2), 273 K273\text{ K} is below its critical temperature (Tc=304.1 KT_c = 304.1\text{ K}) and well below its Boyle temperature (Tb≈714 KT_b \approx 714\text{ K}).
  2. At P=1 atmP = 1\text{ atm}, attractive intermolecular forces are significant, meaning the attractive term an2V2\frac{an^2}{V^2} dominates while the molecular volume nbnb is negligible compared to VV.
  3. Under dominant attractive forces, the pressure is lower than ideal pressure, making Z<1Z < 1, which implies Z≠1Z \neq 1.

Thus, (C) matches with (p) and (q).


(D) Real gas with very large molar volume

  1. When the molar volume Vm=VnV_m = \frac{V}{n} is extremely large (Vm→∞V_m \to \infty), the gas density is extremely low.
  2. The pressure correction term aVm2\frac{a}{V_m^2} drops off as O(1/Vm2)O(1/V_m^2), and the volume correction bVm\frac{b}{V_m} drops off as O(1/Vm)O(1/V_m).
  3. If aVm2\frac{a}{V_m^2} is neglected first, the equation takes the form P(V−nb)=nRTP(V - nb) = nRT.
  4. At very large molar volume, both corrections become completely negligible (an2V2→0\frac{an^2}{V^2} \to 0 and nb≪Vnb \ll V), so the real gas obeys the ideal gas equation:
    PV=nRTPV = nRT

Thus, (D) matches with (r).


Final Matching Summary:

  • A →\rightarrow p, s
  • B →\rightarrow r
  • C →\rightarrow p, q
  • D →\rightarrow r