JEE Challenger
More from Thermodynamics

Irreversible Expansion of Ideal Gas into Vacuum in Insulated Vessel

Suppose an ideal gas is kept within a thermally insulated container at an initial internal pressure P1P_1, volume V1V_1, and absolute temperature T1T_1. It undergoes an irreversible expansion against zero external pressure, as illustrated in the diagram. Let the final internal pressure, volume, and absolute temperature be P2P_2, V2V_2, and T2T_2, respectively. Which of the following conditions hold true for this expansion?

Question Diagram 1

Options

A

q=0q = 0

Correct
B

T2=T1T_2 = T_1

Correct
C

P2V2=P1V1P_2 V_2 = P_1 V_1

Correct
D

P2V2γ=P1V1γP_2 V_2^{\gamma} = P_1 V_1^{\gamma}

Step-by-Step Solution

To determine the correct conditions for the given expansion, we analyze the thermodynamics of the process step-by-step:

  1. Evaluation of Heat Exchange (qq): The container is thermally insulated from the surroundings, which means that no heat can enter or leave the system. Therefore, the process is adiabatic: q=0q = 0 Hence, Option (A) is correct.

  2. Evaluation of Work Done (ww) and Internal Energy Change (ΔU\Delta U): The gas undergoes free expansion into a vacuum, meaning it expands against zero external pressure (Pext=0P_{\text{ext}} = 0). The work done during the expansion is given by: w=−∫Pext dV=0w = -\int P_{\text{ext}} \, dV = 0 According to the First Law of Thermodynamics: ΔU=q+w\Delta U = q + w Substituting q=0q = 0 and w=0w = 0: ΔU=0\Delta U = 0

  3. Evaluation of Temperature (T2=T1T_2 = T_1): For an ideal gas, the internal energy is solely a function of temperature (U=U(T)U = U(T)). Therefore: ΔU=nCv(T2−T1)=0\Delta U = n C_v (T_2 - T_1) = 0 Since nCv≠0n C_v \neq 0, this implies: T2−T1=0  ⟹  T2=T1T_2 - T_1 = 0 \implies T_2 = T_1 Hence, Option (B) is correct.

  4. Evaluation of the PVPV Relationship: Using the ideal gas equation of state PV=nRTPV = nRT for the initial and final states: P1V1=nRT1P_1 V_1 = n R T_1 P2V2=nRT2P_2 V_2 = n R T_2 Since T1=T2T_1 = T_2, it follows directly that: P2V2=P1V1P_2 V_2 = P_1 V_1 Hence, Option (C) is correct.

  5. Evaluation of the Adiabatic Reversible Equation (P2V2γ=P1V1γP_2 V_2^{\gamma} = P_1 V_1^{\gamma}): The relation PVγ=constantP V^{\gamma} = \text{constant} is valid only for a reversible adiabatic process of an ideal gas. For the given irreversible free expansion: P2V2γ=(P2V2)V2γ−1=(P1V1)V2γ−1P_2 V_2^{\gamma} = (P_2 V_2) V_2^{\gamma-1} = (P_1 V_1) V_2^{\gamma-1} Since the gas expands, V2>V1V_2 > V_1, and for any ideal gas γ>1\gamma > 1, we have: (P1V1)V2γ−1≠P1V1γ(P_1 V_1) V_2^{\gamma-1} \neq P_1 V_1^{\gamma} Thus, P2V2γ≠P1V1γP_2 V_2^{\gamma} \neq P_1 V_1^{\gamma}. Hence, Option (D) is incorrect.

Therefore, the correct options are A, B, and C.