JEE Challenger
More from Dual Nature of Radiation and Matter

Incorrect Statement Regarding Continuous and Characteristic X-Rays

Which one of the following statements is WRONG in the context of X-rays generated from a X-ray tube?

Options

A

Wavelength of characteristic X-rays decreases when the atomic number of the target increases

B

Cut-off wavelength of the continuous X-rays depends on the atomic number of the target

Correct
C

Intensity of the characteristic X-rays depends on the electrical power given to the X-ray tube

D

Cut-off wavelength of the continuous X-rays depends on the energy of the electrons in the X-ray tube

Step-by-Step Solution

To determine the incorrect statement, let us analyze each option based on the physics of X-ray production:

  1. Analysis of Characteristic X-rays (Option A):
    According to Moseley's law, the frequency ν\nu of a characteristic X-ray line is related to the atomic number ZZ of the target material by:
    ν=a(Z−b)\sqrt{\nu} = a(Z - b)
    Since the wavelength λ\lambda is inversely proportional to frequency (λ=cν\lambda = \frac{c}{\nu}):
    λ=ca2(Z−b)2\lambda = \frac{c}{a^2(Z - b)^2}
    As the atomic number ZZ increases, the energy difference between the inner shells increases, resulting in an increased frequency ν\nu and a decreased wavelength λ\lambda.
    Therefore, statement (A) is correct.

  2. Analysis of the Cut-off Wavelength of Continuous X-rays (Options B and D):
    The continuous spectrum of X-rays (Bremsstrahlung) is produced when high-energy electrons are decelerated by the target material. The maximum photon energy corresponds to an electron giving up all its kinetic energy in a single collision:
    Emax⁡=hνmax⁡=hcλmin⁡=eVE_{\max} = h\nu_{\max} = \frac{hc}{\lambda_{\min}} = eV
    where:

    • hh is Planck's constant,
    • cc is the speed of light,
    • ee is the elementary charge,
    • VV is the accelerating potential of the tube, and
    • Ek=eVE_k = eV is the kinetic energy of the striking electrons.

    Solving for the minimum (cut-off) wavelength λcut-off\lambda_{\text{cut-off}} (or λmin⁡\lambda_{\min}):
    λcut-off=hceV=hcEk\lambda_{\text{cut-off}} = \frac{hc}{eV} = \frac{hc}{E_k}
    Thus, the cut-off wavelength depends solely on the energy of the incident electrons (accelerating potential VV) and is independent of the nature or atomic number of the target material.
    Therefore, statement (D) is correct, while statement (B) is wrong.

  3. Analysis of Intensity (Option C):
    The intensity of the characteristic X-rays depends on the rate at which target atoms are ionized, which in turn depends on the tube current (number of electrons striking per second) and the accelerating potential (energy per electron). Both of these parameters directly determine the electrical power supplied to the X-ray tube (P=VIP = V I).
    Therefore, statement (C) is correct.

Since the question asks to identify the statement that is WRONG, the correct choice is B.