JEE Challenger
More from Current Electricity

Comparison of Power Dissipation in Three Resistor Configurations

Figure shows three resistor configurations R1, R2 and R3 connected to 3 V3\text{ V} battery. If the power dissipated by the configuration R1, R2 and R3 is P1, P2 and P3, respectively, then

Diagram 0

Options

A

P1>P2>P3\text{P1} > \text{P2} > \text{P3}

B

P1>P3>P2\text{P1} > \text{P3} > \text{P2}

C

P2>P1>P3\text{P2} > \text{P1} > \text{P3}

Correct
D

P3>P2>P1\text{P3} > \text{P2} > \text{P1}

Step-by-Step Solution

To determine the correct relationship between the powers dissipated by the three configurations, we find the equivalent resistance ReqR_{\text{eq}} of each circuit connected across the V=3 VV = 3\text{ V} battery. The power dissipated in each case is given by:
P=V2ReqP = \frac{V^2}{R_{\text{eq}}}


1. Configuration R2R_2:

  • The circuit is a symmetric Wheatstone bridge consisting of five 1 Ω1\,\Omega resistors.
  • The four outer arms each have resistance R=1 ΩR = 1\,\Omega, and the central resistor has resistance R=1 ΩR = 1\,\Omega.
  • The ratio of the resistances of opposite arms is balanced:
    Rtop-leftRbottom-left=1 Ω1 Ω=Rtop-rightRbottom-right\frac{R_{\text{top-left}}}{R_{\text{bottom-left}}} = \frac{1\,\Omega}{1\,\Omega} = \frac{R_{\text{top-right}}}{R_{\text{bottom-right}}}
  • Therefore, the potential difference across the central 1 Ω1\,\Omega resistor is zero, and no current flows through it.
  • The remaining four resistors form two parallel branches, each having two 1 Ω1\,\Omega resistors in series:
    Rbranch=1 Ω+1 Ω=2 ΩR_{\text{branch}} = 1\,\Omega + 1\,\Omega = 2\,\Omega
  • The equivalent resistance of configuration R2R_2 is:
    Req,2=2 Ω×2 Ω2 Ω+2 Ω=1 ΩR_{\text{eq}, 2} = \frac{2\,\Omega \times 2\,\Omega}{2\,\Omega + 2\,\Omega} = 1\,\Omega
  • The power dissipated in configuration R2R_2 is:
    P2=V2Req,2=321=9 WP_2 = \frac{V^2}{R_{\text{eq}, 2}} = \frac{3^2}{1} = 9\text{ W}

2. Configuration R3R_3:

  • Configuration R3R_3 consists of a four-resistor bridge network connected in series with an additional 1 Ω1\,\Omega resistor at the bottom.
  • The upper diamond bridge consists of two parallel branches, each with two 1 Ω1\,\Omega resistors in series:
    Rbridge=(1 Ω+1 Ω)×(1 Ω+1 Ω)(1 Ω+1 Ω)+(1 Ω+1 Ω)=2×22+2=1 ΩR_{\text{bridge}} = \frac{(1\,\Omega + 1\,\Omega) \times (1\,\Omega + 1\,\Omega)}{(1\,\Omega + 1\,\Omega) + (1\,\Omega + 1\,\Omega)} = \frac{2 \times 2}{2 + 2} = 1\,\Omega
  • This bridge is in series with the bottom 1 Ω1\,\Omega resistor:
    Req,3=Rbridge+1 Ω=1 Ω+1 Ω=2 ΩR_{\text{eq}, 3} = R_{\text{bridge}} + 1\,\Omega = 1\,\Omega + 1\,\Omega = 2\,\Omega
  • The power dissipated in configuration R3R_3 is:
    P3=V2Req,3=322=4.5 WP_3 = \frac{V^2}{R_{\text{eq}, 3}} = \frac{3^2}{2} = 4.5\text{ W}

3. Configuration R1R_1:

  • By analyzing the node connections of configuration R1R_1:
    • The parallel and series combinations of the five 1 Ω1\,\Omega resistors reduce to an equivalent resistance of:
      Req,1=1.5 ΩR_{\text{eq}, 1} = 1.5\,\Omega
  • The power dissipated in configuration R1R_1 is:
    P1=V2Req,1=321.5=6 WP_1 = \frac{V^2}{R_{\text{eq}, 1}} = \frac{3^2}{1.5} = 6\text{ W}

Comparison:

Comparing the power dissipated in the three configurations:
P2=9 W,P1=6 W,P3=4.5 WP_2 = 9\text{ W}, \quad P_1 = 6\text{ W}, \quad P_3 = 4.5\text{ W}

Thus:
P2>P1>P3\text{P2} > \text{P1} > \text{P3}

Therefore, the correct option is (C).