JEE Challenger
More from Waves

Frequency Distribution of Sound Intensity in Train A

Comprehension Passage

Two trains AA and BB are moving with speeds 20 m/s20\text{ m/s} and 30 m/s30\text{ m/s} respectively in the same direction on the same straight track, with BB ahead of AA. The engines are at the front ends. The engine of train AA blows a long whistle.

Assume that the sound of the whistle is composed of components varying in frequency from f1=800 Hzf_1 = 800\text{ Hz} to f2=1120 Hzf_2 = 1120\text{ Hz}. The speed of sound in still air is 340 m/s340\text{ m/s}.

The distribution of the sound intensity of the whistle as observed by the passengers in train A is best represented by

Options

A
Option A Diagram 1
Correct
B
Option B Diagram 1
C
Option C Diagram 1
D
Option D Diagram 1

Step-by-Step Solution

Based on the problem setup and the principles of the Doppler effect:

  1. Relative Motion Between Source and Observer:
    The whistle (sound source) is mounted on train A, and the passengers observing the sound are also in train A. Therefore, there is no relative motion between the source and these observers:
    vsource=vobserverv_{\text{source}} = v_{\text{observer}}

  2. Absence of Doppler Shift:
    Since the source of sound and the passengers in train A are at rest relative to each other, no Doppler frequency shift occurs for any emitted frequency.

  3. Frequency Distribution:
    If the whistle emits a continuous distribution of sound frequencies with uniform intensity between the bounds f1f_1 and f2f_2, the observed frequency range will remain completely unchanged. That is, the sound intensity begins precisely at f1f_1 and ends precisely at f2f_2.

Examining the given plots of Intensity versus frequency:

  • In (A), the rectangular pulse of intensity starts sharply at f1f_1 and terminates at f2f_2, representing zero frequency shift.
  • In (B), the frequencies are shifted to lower values.
  • In (C), the frequencies are shifted to higher values.
  • In (D), the frequency bandwidth is stretched.

Thus, the observed intensity distribution in train A is correctly depicted in (A).