JEE Challenger
More from Current Electricity

Filament Resistance Relation of Bulbs at Room Temperature

Incandescent bulbs are designed by keeping in mind that the resistance of their filament increases with the increase in temperature. If at room temperature, 100 W100\text{ W}, 60 W60\text{ W} and 40 W40\text{ W} bulbs have filament resistances R100\text{R}_{100}, R60\text{R}_{60} and R40\text{R}_{40}, respectively, the relation between these resistances is

Options

A

1R100=1R40+1R60\frac{1}{\text{R}_{100}} = \frac{1}{\text{R}_{40}} + \frac{1}{\text{R}_{60}}

B

R100=R40+R60\text{R}_{100} = \text{R}_{40} + \text{R}_{60}

C

R100>R60>R40\text{R}_{100} > \text{R}_{60} > \text{R}_{40}

D

1R100>1R60>1R40\frac{1}{\text{R}_{100}} > \frac{1}{\text{R}_{60}} > \frac{1}{\text{R}_{40}}

Correct

Step-by-Step Solution

To determine the relationship between the filament resistances at room temperature for the given bulbs, we analyze their rated powers and temperature dependence of resistance.

  1. Power Rating and Operating Resistance:
    The rated power PP of an incandescent bulb designed to operate at a standard mains voltage VV is given by:
    P=V2RhotP = \frac{V^2}{R_{\text{hot}}}
    where RhotR_{\text{hot}} is the resistance of the bulb's filament at its operating (hot) temperature.

Rearranging this expression for RhotR_{\text{hot}} gives:
Rhot=V2PR_{\text{hot}} = \frac{V^2}{P}

For the three bulbs rated at 100 W100\text{ W}, 60 W60\text{ W}, and 40 W40\text{ W} operating at the same rated voltage VV:
Rhot,100=V2100R_{\text{hot}, 100} = \frac{V^2}{100}
Rhot,60=V260R_{\text{hot}, 60} = \frac{V^2}{60}
Rhot,40=V240R_{\text{hot}, 40} = \frac{V^2}{40}

Since 100 W>60 W>40 W100\text{ W} > 60\text{ W} > 40\text{ W}, we have:
Rhot,100<Rhot,60<Rhot,40R_{\text{hot}, 100} < R_{\text{hot}, 60} < R_{\text{hot}, 40}

  1. Resistance at Room Temperature:
    The resistance of metallic filaments increases with temperature according to:
    Rhot=Rroom(1+αΔT)R_{\text{hot}} = R_{\text{room}} (1 + \alpha \Delta T)
    where α\alpha is the temperature coefficient of resistance and ΔT\Delta T is the temperature difference between operating temperature and room temperature.

Since the operational design factors are directly proportional, a bulb with a smaller operating resistance RhotR_{\text{hot}} also possesses a smaller resistance RR at room temperature. Thus, the room temperature resistances R100R_{100}, R60R_{60}, and R40R_{40} satisfy:
R100<R60<R40R_{100} < R_{60} < R_{40}

  1. Reciprocal Relation:
    Taking the reciprocal of each resistance reverses the order of the inequalities:
    1R100>1R60>1R40\frac{1}{R_{100}} > \frac{1}{R_{60}} > \frac{1}{R_{40}}

Hence, the correct option is D.