JEE Challenger
More from Kinetic Theory

Diffusion Rate and Force Balance of Potassium Permanganate Solution

As illustrated schematically in the figure, two vessels contain water solutions (at temperature TT) of potassium permanganate (KMnO4\text{KMnO}_4) with differing concentrations n1n_1 and n2n_2 (n1>n2n_1 > n_2) molecules per unit volume, with Δn=(n1−n2)≪n1\Delta n = (n_1 - n_2) \ll n_1. When connected by a narrow tube of small length ll and cross-sectional area SS, KMnO4\text{KMnO}_4 begins to diffuse from the left vessel to the right vessel via the tube. Assume the system of molecules behaves as a dilute ideal gas, with the difference in partial pressure between the two vessels driving the diffusion. The drift speed vv of each molecule is constrained by a viscous force −βv-\beta v, where β\beta is a constant. Neglecting terms of order (Δn)2(\Delta n)^2, which of the following statements is/are correct? (kBk_B represents Boltzmann's constant)

Question Diagram 1

Options

A

the driving force causing the molecules to pass through the tube is ΔnkBTS\Delta n k_B T S

Correct
B

the balance of forces implies n1βvl=ΔnkBTn_1 \beta v l = \Delta n k_B T

Correct
C

the total rate of molecules passing through the tube per second is (Δnl)(kBTβ)S\left(\frac{\Delta n}{l}\right) \left(\frac{k_B T}{\beta}\right) S

Correct
D

the rate at which molecules transfer through the tube does not change with time

Step-by-Step Solution

To determine which of the statements are correct, we analyze the system step-by-step using the principles of ideal gas kinetic theory and fluid dynamics applied to dilute solutions.

1. Driving Force (Option A)

The system of KMnO4\text{KMnO}_4 molecules behaves as a dilute ideal gas. The partial pressure of the molecules in a region with concentration nn at temperature TT is given by: P=nkBTP = n k_B T

The partial pressure difference between the two vessels across the connecting tube of cross-sectional area SS is: ΔP=P1−P2=(n1−n2)kBT=ΔnkBT\Delta P = P_1 - P_2 = (n_1 - n_2) k_B T = \Delta n k_B T

The driving force FdrivingF_{\text{driving}} acting on the fluid within the tube due to this pressure difference is: Fdriving=ΔP⋅S=ΔnkBTSF_{\text{driving}} = \Delta P \cdot S = \Delta n k_B T S

Thus, Option A is correct.


2. Force Balance (Option B)

Since Δn=n1−n2≪n1\Delta n = n_1 - n_2 \ll n_1, the average concentration of KMnO4\text{KMnO}_4 molecules inside the tube can be approximated as n≈n1n \approx n_1.

The volume of the connecting tube is Vtube=SlV_{\text{tube}} = S l. Therefore, the total number of molecules inside the tube is: Ntube≈n1SlN_{\text{tube}} \approx n_1 S l

Each molecule experiences a viscous retarding force of magnitude βv\beta v, where vv is the drift speed. The total retarding force on all molecules in the tube is: Fviscous=Ntube(βv)=n1SlβvF_{\text{viscous}} = N_{\text{tube}} (\beta v) = n_1 S l \beta v

At steady drift motion, the driving force balances the viscous retarding force: Fdriving=FviscousF_{\text{driving}} = F_{\text{viscous}} ΔnkBTS=n1Slβv\Delta n k_B T S = n_1 S l \beta v

Dividing both sides by SS: n1βvl=ΔnkBTn_1 \beta v l = \Delta n k_B T

Thus, Option B is correct.


3. Rate of Molecule Transfer (Option C)

The drift velocity vv of the molecules can be expressed using the force balance relation from Option B: v=ΔnkBTn1βlv = \frac{\Delta n k_B T}{n_1 \beta l}

The total rate of molecules transferring through the tube per second (flux) is given by: dNdt=n1Sv\frac{dN}{dt} = n_1 S v

Substituting the value of vv: dNdt=n1S(ΔnkBTn1βl)=(Δnl)(kBTβ)S\frac{dN}{dt} = n_1 S \left( \frac{\Delta n k_B T}{n_1 \beta l} \right) = \left( \frac{\Delta n}{l} \right) \left( \frac{k_B T}{\beta} \right) S

Thus, Option C is correct.


4. Time Dependence of the Rate (Option D)

As molecules diffuse from the left vessel to the right vessel, the concentration n1n_1 decreases while n2n_2 increases. Consequently, the concentration difference Δn=n1−n2\Delta n = n_1 - n_2 decreases over time.

Since the rate of molecule transfer is directly proportional to Δn\Delta n: dNdt∝Δn\frac{dN}{dt} \propto \Delta n

The transfer rate must decrease exponentially over time as equilibrium is approached. Therefore, it does not remain constant.

Thus, Option D is incorrect.


Conclusion

The correct options are A, B, and C.