JEE Challenger
More from Laws of Motion

Relative Ease of Pulling versus Pushing a Heavy Object

STATEMENT-1
It is easier to pull a heavy object than to push it on a level ground.
and
STATEMENT-2
The magnitude of frictional force depends on the nature of the two surfaces in contact.

Options

A

STATEMENT-1 is True, STATEMENT-2 is True; STATEMENT-2 is a correct explanation for STATEMENT-1

B

STATEMENT-1 is True, STATEMENT-2 is True; STATEMENT-2 is NOT a correct explanation for STATEMENT-1

Correct
C

STATEMENT-1 is True, STATEMENT-2 is False

D

STATEMENT-1 is False, STATEMENT-2 is True

Topics & Concepts

Step-by-Step Solution

To analyze the given statements, we consider the physics of friction and the forces acting on a body during pulling and pushing.


Analysis of STATEMENT-1:

Consider a block of mass mm resting on a rough horizontal ground with a coefficient of friction μ\mu.

  1. Pulling the object:
    When a force FF is applied at an angle θ\theta above the horizontal to pull the object:

    • Balancing forces in the vertical direction gives:
      Npull+Fsin⁡θ=mg  ⟹  Npull=mg−Fsin⁡θN_{\text{pull}} + F\sin\theta = mg \implies N_{\text{pull}} = mg - F\sin\theta
    • The maximum (limiting) frictional force is:
      fpull=μNpull=μ(mg−Fsin⁡θ)f_{\text{pull}} = \mu N_{\text{pull}} = \mu (mg - F\sin\theta)
  2. Pushing the object:
    When a force FF is applied at an angle θ\theta below the horizontal to push the object:

    • Balancing forces in the vertical direction gives:
      Npush=mg+Fsin⁡θN_{\text{push}} = mg + F\sin\theta
    • The maximum (limiting) frictional force is:
      fpush=μNpush=μ(mg+Fsin⁡θ)f_{\text{push}} = \mu N_{\text{push}} = \mu (mg + F\sin\theta)

Comparing the normal reactions and corresponding frictional forces:
Npull<Npush  ⟹  fpull<fpushN_{\text{pull}} < N_{\text{push}} \implies f_{\text{pull}} < f_{\text{push}}

Since the effective frictional force opposing motion is smaller when pulling than when pushing, it is easier to pull a heavy object than to push it on a level ground.

Thus, STATEMENT-1 is True.


Analysis of STATEMENT-2:

The magnitude of the frictional force is given by f=μNf = \mu N, where μ\mu is the coefficient of friction. The value of μ\mu depends on the physical properties, roughness, and material composition of the two surfaces in contact.

Thus, STATEMENT-2 is True.


Relationship between STATEMENT-1 and STATEMENT-2:

STATEMENT-1 is true because pulling reduces the normal reaction force NN (via the upward vertical component Fsin⁡θF\sin\theta), thereby decreasing the frictional resistance. STATEMENT-2 states that friction depends on the nature of the surfaces (which determines μ\mu). While STATEMENT-2 is a correct statement regarding friction, it does not explain why pulling results in a smaller normal reaction than pushing.

Therefore, STATEMENT-2 is NOT the correct explanation for STATEMENT-1.


Conclusion:

  • STATEMENT-1 is True.
  • STATEMENT-2 is True.
  • STATEMENT-2 is NOT a correct explanation for STATEMENT-1.

Correct Answer: (B)