JEE Challenger
More from Ray Optics and Optical Instruments

Refraction Through Two Isosceles Prisms and Plane Mirror

Consider two isosceles prisms 1 and 2 with prism angles A1A_1 and A2A_2 and refractive indices n1n_1 and n2n_2, respectively, as shown in the figure. The faces a1b1a_1b_1 and a2b2a_2b_2 are parallel to each other and perpendicular to the mirror MM. If a ray of light is incident on the face a1c1a_1c_1 and emerges from the face a2c2a_2c_2, then the correct statement(s) is/are:

Question Diagram 1

Options

A

If both the prisms are at minimum deviation condition, then n2n1=sin(A12)/sin(A22)\frac{n_2}{n_1} = \sin\left(\frac{A_1}{2}\right) / \sin\left(\frac{A_2}{2}\right).

Correct
B

If prism 2 is at minimum deviation condition, then sini1=n2sin(A22)\sin i_1 = n_2 \sin\left(\frac{A_2}{2}\right) is always true.

C

If both the prisms 1 and 2 are thin and are at minimum deviation condition with angles of deviation δm1\delta_{m1} and δm2\delta_{m2}, respectively, then θ=δm12(n11)+δm22(n21)\theta = \frac{\delta_{m1}}{2(n_1-1)} + \frac{\delta_{m2}}{2(n_2-1)}.

Correct
D

If prism 1 is at minimum deviation condition, then sini2=n1sin(A12)\sin i_2 = n_1 \sin\left(\frac{A_1}{2}\right) is always true.

Correct

Step-by-Step Solution

To analyze the given optical setup, we first use geometric optics to find the relationship between the angles of light propagation through the two prisms and the plane mirror MM.

1. Geometric Relation Between Prisms 1 and 2

  • The faces a1b1a_1b_1 and a2b2a_2b_2 are given to be parallel to each other and perpendicular to the plane mirror MM.
  • Taking the plane of mirror MM to be horizontal, the normals to the faces a1b1a_1b_1 and a2b2a_2b_2 are both horizontal.
  • Let a ray of light emerge from face a1b1a_1b_1 of Prism 1 at an angle of emergence e1e_1 with respect to the normal of face a1b1a_1b_1. The ray thus makes an angle e1e_1 with the horizontal.
  • The ray reflects off the horizontal plane mirror MM. By the law of reflection, the angle of the reflected ray with the horizontal remains e1e_1.
  • Since the normal to face a2b2a_2b_2 of Prism 2 is also horizontal, the angle of incidence i2i_2 at face a2b2a_2b_2 must be equal to the angle of emergence e1e_1 from face a1b1a_1b_1: i2=e1i_2 = e_1

2. Analysis of Option A

For Prism 1 at minimum deviation condition:

  • The angle of refraction at the internal surface is r1=r1=A12r_1 = r_1' = \frac{A_1}{2}.
  • Applying Snell's law at the emerging face a1b1a_1b_1: sine1=n1sin(A12)\sin e_1 = n_1 \sin\left(\frac{A_1}{2}\right)

For Prism 2 at minimum deviation condition:

  • The angle of refraction at the internal surface is r2=r2=A22r_2 = r_2' = \frac{A_2}{2}.
  • Applying Snell's law at the incident face a2b2a_2b_2: sini2=n2sin(A22)\sin i_2 = n_2 \sin\left(\frac{A_2}{2}\right)

Since i2=e1i_2 = e_1, we have sini2=sine1\sin i_2 = \sin e_1, which yields: n1sin(A12)=n2sin(A22)n_1 \sin\left(\frac{A_1}{2}\right) = n_2 \sin\left(\frac{A_2}{2}\right)     n2n1=sin(A12)sin(A22)\implies \frac{n_2}{n_1} = \frac{\sin\left(\frac{A_1}{2}\right)}{\sin\left(\frac{A_2}{2}\right)}

Thus, Option A is correct.


3. Analysis of Option D

If Prism 1 is at minimum deviation condition, we have: sine1=n1sin(A12)\sin e_1 = n_1 \sin\left(\frac{A_1}{2}\right)

Using the relation i2=e1i_2 = e_1, it directly follows that: sini2=n1sin(A12)\sin i_2 = n_1 \sin\left(\frac{A_1}{2}\right)

This relation holds universally whenever Prism 1 is at minimum deviation, regardless of the parameters or state of Prism 2.

Thus, Option D is correct.


4. Analysis of Option B

If Prism 2 is at minimum deviation condition, we have: sini2=n2sin(A22)    sine1=n2sin(A22)\sin i_2 = n_2 \sin\left(\frac{A_2}{2}\right) \implies \sin e_1 = n_2 \sin\left(\frac{A_2}{2}\right)

For sini1=n2sin(A22)\sin i_1 = n_2 \sin\left(\frac{A_2}{2}\right) to hold, we would require i1=e1i_1 = e_1, which is only true if Prism 1 is also at minimum deviation condition. Since Prism 1 is not specified to be at minimum deviation, this statement is not always true.

Thus, Option B is incorrect.


5. Analysis of Option C

  • The face a1b1a_1b_1 is vertical and forms an angle A1A_1 with face a1c1a_1c_1.
  • The face a2b2a_2b_2 is vertical and forms an angle A2A_2 with face a2c2a_2c_2.
  • Since a1b1a2b2a_1b_1 \parallel a_2b_2, the angle θ\theta between the extended surfaces a1c1a_1c_1 and a2c2a_2c_2 is given by: θ=A1+A2\theta = A_1 + A_2

For a full thin isosceles prism with minimum deviation angle δm\delta_{m}, the angle of deviation is related to the half-angle by δm=2(n1)A\delta_{m} = 2(n-1)A, which gives: A1=δm12(n11)andA2=δm22(n21)A_1 = \frac{\delta_{m1}}{2(n_1 - 1)} \quad \text{and} \quad A_2 = \frac{\delta_{m2}}{2(n_2 - 1)}

Substituting A1A_1 and A2A_2 into the expression for θ\theta: θ=δm12(n11)+δm22(n21)\theta = \frac{\delta_{m1}}{2(n_1-1)} + \frac{\delta_{m2}}{2(n_2-1)}

Thus, Option C is correct.


Conclusion

The correct options are A, C, and D.

Refraction Through Two Isosceles Prisms and Plane Mirror | Physics PYQ Solution - JEE Challenger