Reaction Type and Oxidation States in Phosphorus Disproportionation
When white phosphorus reacts with aqueous , phosphine is produced alongside another phosphorus-containing compound. The reaction type, as well as the oxidation states of phosphorus in phosphine and the other product, are respectively
This question was dropped / full marks were awarded to all candidates in the official answer key by the exam conducting body due to an ambiguity or error in the question or options.
Options
redox reaction; and
redox reaction; and
disproportionation reaction; and
disproportionation reaction; and
Step-by-Step Solution
The reaction of white phosphorus () with an aqueous solution of sodium hydroxide () under an inert atmosphere proceeds according to the balanced equation:
Here, phosphine () is produced along with sodium hypophosphite ().
1. Determination of Oxidation States:
-
In elemental white phosphorus ():
-
In phosphine (): Since hydrogen is less electronegative than phosphorus (or taking as ):
-
In sodium hypophosphite (): Using the standard oxidation states for (), (), and (): Thus, the oxidation state of phosphorus in is .
2. Type of Reaction:
Phosphorus undergoes simultaneous:
- Reduction: from an oxidation state of in to in .
- Oxidation: from an oxidation state of in to in .
A reaction in which the same element is simultaneously oxidized and reduced is classified as a disproportionation reaction (which is a specific class of redox reactions).
Conclusion:
The correct description is:
- Reaction type: Disproportionation reaction
- Oxidation states of phosphorus: (in ) and (in )
Since none of the options list the correct oxidation state pair of and , there is no correct option among the choices provided (hence, this question was awarded Marks to All / Zero Marks to all).