JEE Challenger
More from p-Block Elements (Group 15-18)
ChemMedMarks to AllAdv 2012 • Paper 2

Reaction Type and Oxidation States in Phosphorus Disproportionation

When white phosphorus reacts with aqueous NaOH\text{NaOH}, phosphine is produced alongside another phosphorus-containing compound. The reaction type, as well as the oxidation states of phosphorus in phosphine and the other product, are respectively

Official Notice: Marks Awarded to All

This question was dropped / full marks were awarded to all candidates in the official answer key by the exam conducting body due to an ambiguity or error in the question or options.

Options

A

redox reaction; −3-3 and −5-5

B

redox reaction; +3+3 and +5+5

C

disproportionation reaction; −3-3 and +5+5

D

disproportionation reaction; −3-3 and +3+3

Step-by-Step Solution

The reaction of white phosphorus (P4\text{P}_4) with an aqueous solution of sodium hydroxide (NaOH\text{NaOH}) under an inert atmosphere proceeds according to the balanced equation:

P4 (s)+3NaOH (aq)+3H2O (l)⟶PH3 (g)+3NaH2PO2 (aq)\text{P}_4\text{ (s)} + 3\text{NaOH}\text{ (aq)} + 3\text{H}_2\text{O}\text{ (l)} \longrightarrow \text{PH}_3\text{ (g)} + 3\text{NaH}_2\text{PO}_2\text{ (aq)}

Here, phosphine (PH3\text{PH}_3) is produced along with sodium hypophosphite (NaH2PO2\text{NaH}_2\text{PO}_2).

1. Determination of Oxidation States:

  1. In elemental white phosphorus (P4\text{P}_4): Oxidation state of P=0\text{Oxidation state of P} = 0

  2. In phosphine (PH3\text{PH}_3): Since hydrogen is less electronegative than phosphorus (or taking H\text{H} as +1+1): Oxidation state of P+3(+1)=0  ⟹  Oxidation state of P=−3\text{Oxidation state of P} + 3(+1) = 0 \implies \text{Oxidation state of P} = -3

  3. In sodium hypophosphite (NaH2PO2\text{NaH}_2\text{PO}_2): Using the standard oxidation states for Na\text{Na} (+1+1), H\text{H} (+1+1), and O\text{O} (−2-2): (+1)+2(+1)+x+2(−2)=0(+1) + 2(+1) + x + 2(-2) = 0 1+2+x−4=0  ⟹  x=+11 + 2 + x - 4 = 0 \implies x = +1 Thus, the oxidation state of phosphorus in NaH2PO2\text{NaH}_2\text{PO}_2 is +1+1.


2. Type of Reaction:

Phosphorus undergoes simultaneous:

  • Reduction: from an oxidation state of 00 in P4\text{P}_4 to −3-3 in PH3\text{PH}_3.
  • Oxidation: from an oxidation state of 00 in P4\text{P}_4 to +1+1 in NaH2PO2\text{NaH}_2\text{PO}_2.

A reaction in which the same element is simultaneously oxidized and reduced is classified as a disproportionation reaction (which is a specific class of redox reactions).


Conclusion:

The correct description is:

  • Reaction type: Disproportionation reaction
  • Oxidation states of phosphorus: −3-3 (in PH3\text{PH}_3) and +1+1 (in NaH2PO2\text{NaH}_2\text{PO}_2)

Since none of the options list the correct oxidation state pair of −3-3 and +1+1, there is no correct option among the choices provided (hence, this question was awarded Marks to All / Zero Marks to all).