JEE Challenger
More from Complex Numbers and Quadratic Equations

Properties of the Solution Set for a Complex Equation

Let s,t,rs, t, r be non-zero complex numbers, and let LL denote the set of solutions z=x+iyz = x + iy (x,y∈Rx, y \in \mathbb{R}, i=−1i = \sqrt{-1}) satisfying the relation sz+tzˉ+r=0sz + t\bar{z} + r = 0, where zˉ=x−iy\bar{z} = x - iy. Which of the following statements is/are TRUE?

Options

A

If LL contains precisely one element, then ∣s∣≠∣t∣|s| \neq |t|

Correct
B

If ∣s∣=∣t∣|s| = |t|, then LL contains infinitely many elements

C

The total number of elements in L∩{z:∣z−1+i∣=5}L \cap \{z : |z - 1 + i| = 5\} is at most 22

Correct
D

If LL contains more than one element, then LL possesses infinitely many elements

Correct

Step-by-Step Solution

To determine which of the statements are true, we analyze the given complex equation: sz+tzˉ+r=0— (1)sz + t\bar{z} + r = 0 \quad \text{--- (1)}

Taking the complex conjugate of both sides of equation (1), we obtain: sˉzˉ+tˉz+rˉ=0  ⟹  tˉz+sˉzˉ+rˉ=0— (2)\bar{s}\bar{z} + \bar{t}z + \bar{r} = 0 \implies \bar{t}z + \bar{s}\bar{z} + \bar{r} = 0 \quad \text{--- (2)}

We can write equations (1) and (2) as a system of linear equations in zz and zˉ\bar{z}:

(sttˉsˉ)(zzˉ)=(−r−rˉ)\begin{pmatrix} s & t \\ \bar{t} & \bar{s} \end{pmatrix} \begin{pmatrix} z \\ \bar{z} \end{pmatrix} = \begin{pmatrix} -r \\ -\bar{r} \end{pmatrix}

The determinant of the coefficient matrix is: D=ssˉ−ttˉ=∣s∣2−∣t∣2D = s\bar{s} - t\bar{t} = |s|^2 - |t|^2


Analysis of Options:

Option (A):

  • If ∣s∣≠∣t∣|s| \neq |t|, then D≠0D \neq 0. The system has a unique solution given by Cramer's rule: z=−rsˉ+trˉ∣s∣2−∣t∣2=trˉ−rsˉ∣s∣2−∣t∣2z = \frac{-r\bar{s} + t\bar{r}}{|s|^2 - |t|^2} = \frac{t\bar{r} - r\bar{s}}{|s|^2 - |t|^2}
  • If ∣s∣=∣t∣|s| = |t|, then D=0D = 0. A system of linear equations with D=0D = 0 either has no solution or infinitely many solutions; it can never have a unique solution.
  • Therefore, if LL contains precisely one element, we must have ∣s∣≠∣t∣|s| \neq |t|.

Thus, Option (A) is TRUE.


Option (B):

  • Let s=1s = 1, t=1t = 1, and r=ir = i. Note that ∣s∣=∣t∣=1|s| = |t| = 1.
  • Substituting these into the original equation gives: z+zˉ+i=0z + \bar{z} + i = 0
  • Writing z=x+iyz = x + iy (where x,y∈Rx, y \in \mathbb{R}), we have: 2x+i=0  ⟹  2x=−i2x + i = 0 \implies 2x = -i
  • Since x∈Rx \in \mathbb{R}, this equation has no solution, so L=∅L = \emptyset (contains 00 elements).
  • Thus, ∣s∣=∣t∣|s| = |t| does not guarantee infinitely many elements.

Thus, Option (B) is FALSE.


Option (C):

  • Writing z=x+iyz = x + iy, s=s1+is2s = s_1 + i s_2, t=t1+it2t = t_1 + i t_2, and r=r1+ir2r = r_1 + i r_2, equation (1) splits into two real linear equations in xx and yy: Re(sz+tzˉ+r)=(s1+t1)x+(−s2+t2)y+r1=0\text{Re}(sz + t\bar{z} + r) = (s_1 + t_1)x + (-s_2 + t_2)y + r_1 = 0 Im(sz+tzˉ+r)=(s2+t2)x+(s1−t1)y+r2=0\text{Im}(sz + t\bar{z} + r) = (s_2 + t_2)x + (s_1 - t_1)y + r_2 = 0
  • Geometric locus of LL in the Cartesian plane R2\mathbb{R}^2 can only be:
    1. An empty set ∅\emptyset,
    2. A single point (x0,y0)(x_0, y_0),
    3. A straight line.
  • The set {z:∣z−1+i∣=5}\{z : |z - 1 + i| = 5\} represents a circle with center (1,−1)(1, -1) and radius 55.
  • A circle can intersect a straight line at most 22 times, a single point at most 11 time, and an empty set 00 times.
  • Hence, L∩{z:∣z−1+i∣=5}L \cap \{z : |z - 1 + i| = 5\} contains at most 22 elements.

Thus, Option (C) is TRUE.


Option (D):

  • As shown in the geometric classification above, LL can only be an empty set, a single point, or a straight line.
  • If LL has more than one element, it cannot be empty or a single point; hence, LL must be a straight line.
  • A straight line contains infinitely many elements.

Thus, Option (D) is TRUE.


Conclusion:

The correct statements are A, C, and D.