JEE Challenger
More from Moving Charges and Magnetism

Magnetic Field Due to Two Concentric Circular Loops

Two concentric circular loops, one having a radius RR and the second having radius 2R2R, are situated in the xyxy-plane with their common center at the origin as shown in the diagram. The smaller loop carries an anti-clockwise current I1I_1, and the larger loop carries a clockwise current I2I_2, such that I2>2I1I_2 > 2I_1. The vector B⃗(x,y)\vec{B}(x, y) represents the net magnetic field at a position (x,y)(x, y) in the xyxy-plane. Which of the following options is/are correct?

Question Diagram 1

Options

A

B⃗(x,y)\vec{B}(x, y) is oriented perpendicular to the xyxy-plane at every point in the plane

Correct
B

∣B⃗(x,y)∣|\vec{B}(x, y)| depends on xx and yy purely via the radial coordinate r=x2+y2r = \sqrt{x^2 + y^2}

Correct
C

The magnitude ∣B⃗(x,y)∣|\vec{B}(x, y)| remains non-zero for every point satisfying r<Rr < R

D

B⃗(x,y)\vec{B}(x, y) is directed normally outwards from the xyxy-plane at all points lying between the two loops

Step-by-Step Solution

To determine the correct options, let us analyze the magnetic field B⃗(x,y)\vec{B}(x, y) produced by the two concentric circular loops placed in the xyxy-plane with their common center at the origin (0,0)(0, 0).


1. Direction of Magnetic Field (Option A)

By the Biot-Savart Law, the magnetic field at a position vector r⃗=xi^+yj^\vec{r} = x\hat{i} + y\hat{j} in the xyxy-plane due to a current element Idℓ⃗I d\vec{\ell} at r⃗′=x′i^+y′j^\vec{r}' = x'\hat{i} + y'\hat{j} is given by: dB⃗(r⃗)=μ0I4πdℓ⃗×(r⃗−r⃗′)∣r⃗−r⃗′∣3d\vec{B}(\vec{r}) = \frac{\mu_0 I}{4\pi} \frac{d\vec{\ell} \times (\vec{r} - \vec{r}')}{|\vec{r} - \vec{r}'|^3}

Since both the loops and the position vector r⃗\vec{r} lie entirely in the xyxy-plane: dℓ⃗=dx′i^+dy′j^d\vec{\ell} = dx'\hat{i} + dy'\hat{j} r⃗−r⃗′=(x−x′)i^+(y−y′)j^\vec{r} - \vec{r}' = (x - x')\hat{i} + (y - y')\hat{j}

The cross product dℓ⃗×(r⃗−r⃗′)d\vec{\ell} \times (\vec{r} - \vec{r}') has components only along the zz-axis (k^\hat{k}). Integrating over both loops gives: B⃗(x,y)=Bz(x,y)k^\vec{B}(x, y) = B_z(x, y) \hat{k}

Thus, B⃗(x,y)\vec{B}(x, y) is oriented perpendicular to the xyxy-plane at every point in the plane.

Option A is CORRECT.


2. Radial Symmetry (Option B)

Both loops are circular and centered at the origin (0,0)(0, 0). The current distribution possesses continuous rotational symmetry about the zz-axis.

Consequently, the magnitude and direction of the magnetic field depend solely on the distance r=x2+y2r = \sqrt{x^2 + y^2} from the origin: ∣B⃗(x,y)∣=B(r)|\vec{B}(x, y)| = B(r)

Option B is CORRECT.


3. Magnetic Field inside the Smaller Loop (r<Rr < R) (Option C)

Let the unit vector perpendicular to the xyxy-plane pointing outwards be +k^+\hat{k}.

  • The smaller loop carries an anti-clockwise current I1I_1, producing a magnetic field in the +k^+\hat{k} direction inside r<Rr < R.
  • The larger loop carries a clockwise current I2I_2, producing a magnetic field in the −k^-\hat{k} direction inside r<2Rr < 2R.

At the center (r=0)(r = 0), the net magnetic field is: Bz(0)=μ0I12R−μ0I22(2R)=μ02R(I1−I22)B_z(0) = \frac{\mu_0 I_1}{2R} - \frac{\mu_0 I_2}{2(2R)} = \frac{\mu_0}{2R} \left( I_1 - \frac{I_2}{2} \right)

Given that I2>2I1I_2 > 2I_1, we have I1−I22<0I_1 - \frac{I_2}{2} < 0, which implies: Bz(0)<0  ⟹  B⃗(0) points along −k^B_z(0) < 0 \quad \implies \quad \vec{B}(0) \text{ points along } -\hat{k}

As r→R−r \to R^-, the point approaches the wire of the smaller loop carrying current I1I_1. The contribution from I1I_1 diverges to +∞+\infty along +k^+\hat{k}, while the contribution from I2I_2 remains finite: lim⁡r→R−Bz(r)=+∞\lim_{r \to R^-} B_z(r) = +\infty

Since Bz(r)B_z(r) is a continuous function of rr on the interval [0,R)[0, R), by the Intermediate Value Theorem, there must exist at least one radial distance r0∈(0,R)r_0 \in (0, R) where: Bz(r0)=0  ⟹  ∣B⃗(r0)∣=0B_z(r_0) = 0 \quad \implies \quad |\vec{B}(r_0)| = 0

Therefore, ∣B⃗(x,y)∣|\vec{B}(x, y)| does NOT remain non-zero for all points satisfying r<Rr < R.

Option C is INCORRECT.


4. Magnetic Field between the Loops (R<r<2RR < r < 2R) (Option D)

For any point in the region R<r<2RR < r < 2R:

  1. The point lies outside the inner loop of radius RR. The anti-clockwise current I1I_1 produces a magnetic field directed into the plane (−k^-\hat{k}) in the region outside its radius (r>Rr > R).
  2. The point lies inside the outer loop of radius 2R2R. The clockwise current I2I_2 produces a magnetic field directed into the plane (−k^-\hat{k}) in the region inside its radius (r<2Rr < 2R).

Since both magnetic field contributions are directed into the plane (−k^-\hat{k}), the net field B⃗(x,y)\vec{B}(x, y) points normally inwards (into the plane), not outwards.

Option D is INCORRECT.


Conclusion

The correct options are A and B.