JEE Challenger
More from Electrochemistry

Incorrect Statement Regarding General Redox Reaction and Cell Work

For a general redox reaction

Anode Red1Ox1n1++n1e\text{Red}_1 \rightarrow \text{Ox}_1^{n_1^+} + n_1 e^-

Cathode Ox2+n2eRed2n2\text{Ox}_2 + n_2 e^- \rightarrow \text{Red}_2^{n_2^-}

Which of the following statement is incorrect?

Options

A

The overall reaction can be written as n2Red1+n1Ox2n2Ox1n1++n1Red2n2n_2 \text{Red}_1 + n_1 \text{Ox}_2 \rightleftharpoons n_2 \text{Ox}_1^{n_1^+} + n_1 \text{Red}_2^{n_2^-}

B

The electrons do not appear in the overall reaction because electrons produced at the anode are consumed at the cathode.

C

Here nn is the number of electrons transferred in redox reaction.

Option C
D

If the reaction is carried out reversibly, the electrical work done is equal to the ratio of charge and potential difference through which charge is moved.

Correct

Topics & Concepts

Step-by-Step Solution

To determine which statement is incorrect regarding the general redox reaction and electrochemical cell work, we analyze each option:

  1. Overall Reaction (Option A):
    Multiplying the anode half-reaction by n2n_2 and the cathode half-reaction by n1n_1: Anode: n2Red1n2Ox1n1++n1n2e\text{Anode: } n_2 \text{Red}_1 \rightarrow n_2 \text{Ox}_1^{n_1^+} + n_1 n_2 e^- Cathode: n1Ox2+n1n2en1Red2n2\text{Cathode: } n_1 \text{Ox}_2 + n_1 n_2 e^- \rightarrow n_1 \text{Red}_2^{n_2^-} Adding both half-reactions yields the balanced overall cell reaction: n2Red1+n1Ox2n2Ox1n1++n1Red2n2n_2 \text{Red}_1 + n_1 \text{Ox}_2 \rightleftharpoons n_2 \text{Ox}_1^{n_1^+} + n_1 \text{Red}_2^{n_2^-} Therefore, statement A is correct.

  2. Electron Balance (Option B):
    The electrons generated at the anode are completely consumed at the cathode to maintain charge conservation, meaning no free electrons appear in the overall balanced reaction. Therefore, statement B is correct.

  3. Number of Electrons nn (Option C):
    In the Nernst equation for the cell potential, n=n1n2n = n_1 n_2 represents the total number of moles of electrons transferred in the balanced redox equation. Therefore, statement C is correct.

  4. Electrical Work Done (Option D):
    The maximum electrical work done (WelecW_{\text{elec}}) by a reversible electrochemical cell is given by the product of the total charge (q=nFq = nF) and the potential difference (EcellE_{\text{cell}}): Welec=qEcellW_{\text{elec}} = q \cdot E_{\text{cell}} The statement claims that electrical work is equal to the ratio of charge and potential difference, which is mathematically and physically incorrect (WqEcellW \neq \frac{q}{E_{\text{cell}}}).

Thus, statement D is the incorrect statement.

Correct Answer: D

Incorrect Statement Regarding General Redox Reaction and Cell Work | Chemistry PYQ Solution - JEE Challenger