JEE Challenger
More from Chemical Bonding and Molecular Structure

Identify Pairs of Species Without Similar Lewis Dot Structures

The pairs among A=[SO32,CO32],B=[O22,F2],C=[CN,CO],D=[NH3,H3O+] andA = [\text{SO}_3^{2-}, \text{CO}_3^{2-}], B = [\text{O}_2^{2-}, \text{F}_2], C = [\text{CN}^-, \text{CO}], D = [\text{NH}_3, \text{H}_3\text{O}^+] \text{ and} E=[MnO4,CrO42]E = [\text{MnO}_4^-, \text{CrO}_4^{2-}] that do not have similar Lewis dot structure are

Options

A

A, B and E

B

A and E

Correct
C

B, C and D

D

C and D

Step-by-Step Solution

To determine which pairs of species do not have similar Lewis dot structures, we evaluate the total number of valence electrons, the formal charges, hybridization, and the resulting Lewis structures for each given pair:


Pair A: [SO32,CO32][\text{SO}_3^{2-}, \text{CO}_3^{2-}]

  1. SO32\text{SO}_3^{2-} (Sulfite ion):

    • Total valence electrons = 6(from S)+3×6(from O)+2(negative charge)=26 electrons6 \,(\text{from S}) + 3 \times 6 \,(\text{from O}) + 2 \,(\text{negative charge}) = 26\text{ electrons}.
    • Central atom: S\text{S} forms 3 single bonds with oxygen atoms and retains 11 lone pair.
    • Geometry / Shape: Trigonal pyramidal (sp3\text{sp}^3 hybridized central atom).
  2. CO32\text{CO}_3^{2-} (Carbonate ion):

    • Total valence electrons = 4(from C)+3×6(from O)+2(negative charge)=24 electrons4 \,(\text{from C}) + 3 \times 6 \,(\text{from O}) + 2 \,(\text{negative charge}) = 24\text{ electrons}.
    • Central atom: C\text{C} forms 11 double bond and 22 single bonds with oxygen atoms (0 lone pairs on C\text{C}).
    • Geometry / Shape: Trigonal planar (sp2\text{sp}^2 hybridized central atom).

Since SO32\text{SO}_3^{2-} and CO32\text{CO}_3^{2-} have a different number of valence electrons (2626 vs 2424) and different molecular geometries, Pair A does not have similar Lewis dot structures.


Pair B: [O22,F2][\text{O}_2^{2-}, \text{F}_2]

  1. O22\text{O}_2^{2-} (Peroxide ion):

    • Total valence electrons = 2×6+2=14 electrons2 \times 6 + 2 = 14\text{ electrons}.
    • Structure: [:O¨O¨:]2[:\ddot{\text{O}}-\ddot{\text{O}}:]^{2-} (single bond with 3 lone pairs on each oxygen atom).
  2. F2\text{F}_2 (Fluorine molecule):

    • Total valence electrons = 2×7=14 electrons2 \times 7 = 14\text{ electrons}.
    • Structure: :F¨F¨::\ddot{\text{F}}-\ddot{\text{F}}: (single bond with 3 lone pairs on each fluorine atom).

Both species are isoelectronic and possess identical Lewis dot structures.


Pair C: [CN,CO][\text{CN}^-, \text{CO}]

  1. CN\text{CN}^- (Cyanide ion):

    • Total valence electrons = 4(from C)+5(from N)+1=10 electrons4 \,(\text{from C}) + 5 \,(\text{from N}) + 1 = 10\text{ electrons}.
    • Structure: [:CN:][:\text{C}\equiv\text{N}:]^- (triple bond with 1 lone pair on C\text{C} and 1 lone pair on N\text{N}).
  2. CO\text{CO} (Carbon monoxide):

    • Total valence electrons = 4(from C)+6(from O)=10 electrons4 \,(\text{from C}) + 6 \,(\text{from O}) = 10\text{ electrons}.
    • Structure: :CO::\text{C}\equiv\text{O}: (triple bond with 1 lone pair on C\text{C} and 1 lone pair on O\text{O}).

Both species are isoelectronic and possess identical Lewis dot structures.


Pair D: [NH3,H3O+][\text{NH}_3, \text{H}_3\text{O}^+]

  1. NH3\text{NH}_3 (Ammonia):

    • Total valence electrons = 5(from N)+3×1(from H)=8 electrons5 \,(\text{from N}) + 3 \times 1 \,(\text{from H}) = 8\text{ electrons}.
    • Structure: Central N\text{N} forms 3 single bonds with H\text{H} and has 1 lone pair (Trigonal pyramidal).
  2. H3O+\text{H}_3\text{O}^+ (Hydronium ion):

    • Total valence electrons = 6(from O)+3×1(from H)1=8 electrons6 \,(\text{from O}) + 3 \times 1 \,(\text{from H}) - 1 = 8\text{ electrons}.
    • Structure: Central O\text{O} forms 3 single bonds with H\text{H} and has 1 lone pair (Trigonal pyramidal).

Both species are isoelectronic and possess similar Lewis dot structures.


Pair E: [MnO4,CrO42][\text{MnO}_4^-, \text{CrO}_4^{2-}]

  1. MnO4\text{MnO}_4^- (Permanganate ion):

    • Manganese (Mn\text{Mn}) has 7 valence electrons (3d54s23d^5 4s^2).
    • To minimize formal charge, Mn\text{Mn} forms 3 double bonds (Mn=O\text{Mn}=\text{O}) and 1 single bond (MnO\text{Mn}-\text{O}^-).
  2. CrO42\text{CrO}_4^{2-} (Chromate ion):

    • Chromium (Cr\text{Cr}) has 6 valence electrons (3d54s13d^5 4s^1).
    • To minimize formal charge, Cr\text{Cr} forms 2 double bonds (Cr=O\text{Cr}=\text{O}) and 2 single bonds (CrO\text{Cr}-\text{O}^-).

Since the number of double bonds and single bonds around the central metal atom differs between MnO4\text{MnO}_4^- and CrO42\text{CrO}_4^{2-}, Pair E does not have similar Lewis dot structures.


Conclusion:

The pairs that do not have similar Lewis dot structures are A and E.

Correct Option: B

Identify Pairs of Species Without Similar Lewis Dot Structures | Chemistry PYQ Solution - JEE Challenger