JEE Challenger
More from Matrices

Identify Incorrect Statements regarding Properties of Square Matrices

For two 3×33 \times 3 matrices MM and NN, select the statement(s) which is/are NOT correct:

Options

A

NTMNN^T M N is symmetric or skew-symmetric, depending on whether MM is symmetric or skew-symmetric

B

MN−NMMN - NM is skew-symmetric for every pair of symmetric matrices MM and NN

C

MNMN is symmetric for all symmetric matrices MM and NN

Correct
D

(adj M)(adj N)=adj (MN)(\text{adj } M)(\text{adj } N) = \text{adj }(MN) for all invertible matrices MM and NN

Correct

Topics & Concepts

Step-by-Step Solution

To determine which of the statements are NOT correct, we analyze each option individually for two 3×33 \times 3 matrices MM and NN:

Option (A): Consider the matrix A=NTMNA = N^T M N. Taking the transpose on both sides: AT=(NTMN)T=NTMT(NT)T=NTMTNA^T = (N^T M N)^T = N^T M^T (N^T)^T = N^T M^T N

  • If MM is symmetric (MT=MM^T = M), then: AT=NTMN=AA^T = N^T M N = A Hence, NTMNN^T M N is symmetric.
  • If MM is skew-symmetric (MT=−MM^T = -M), then: AT=NT(−M)N=−NTMN=−AA^T = N^T (-M) N = -N^T M N = -A Hence, NTMNN^T M N is skew-symmetric.

Therefore, statement (A) is correct.


Option (B): Let MM and NN be symmetric matrices, which means MT=MM^T = M and NT=NN^T = N. Consider the matrix B=MN−NMB = MN - NM. Taking the transpose: BT=(MN−NM)T=(MN)T−(NM)T=NTMT−MTNTB^T = (MN - NM)^T = (MN)^T - (NM)^T = N^T M^T - M^T N^T Substituting MT=MM^T = M and NT=NN^T = N: BT=NM−MN=−(MN−NM)=−BB^T = NM - MN = -(MN - NM) = -B Since BT=−BB^T = -B, the matrix MN−NMMN - NM is always skew-symmetric.

Therefore, statement (B) is correct.


Option (C): Let MM and NN be symmetric matrices. Taking the transpose of their product MNMN: (MN)T=NTMT=NM(MN)^T = N^T M^T = NM For MNMN to be symmetric, we must have (MN)T=MN(MN)^T = MN, which implies: NM=MNNM = MN Since two symmetric matrices do not necessarily commute, MNMN is not necessarily symmetric for all symmetric matrices MM and NN.

Therefore, statement (C) is NOT correct.


Option (D): Recall the property of the adjugate of a product of two square matrices: adj(MN)=(adj N)(adj M)\text{adj}(MN) = (\text{adj } N)(\text{adj } M) In general, matrix multiplication is non-commutative, so: (adj M)(adj N)≠(adj N)(adj M)(\text{adj } M)(\text{adj } N) \neq (\text{adj } N)(\text{adj } M) Thus, (adj M)(adj N)≠adj(MN)(\text{adj } M)(\text{adj } N) \neq \text{adj}(MN) in general.

Therefore, statement (D) is NOT correct.


Since the question asks to identify the statements that are NOT correct, the correct options are C and D.