JEE Challenger
More from Mechanical Properties of Fluids

Height of Water Column Inside Submerged Inverted Cylinder

The piston is taken completely out of the cylinder. The hole at the top is sealed. A water tank is brought below the cylinder and put in a position so that the water surface in the tank is at the same level as the top of the cylinder as shown in the figure.

Diagram 0

The density of the water is ρ\rho. In equilibrium, the height HH of the water column in the cylinder satisfies

Options

A

ρg(L0−H)2+P0(L0−H)+L0P0=0\rho g(L_0 - H)^2 + P_0(L_0 - H) + L_0 P_0 = 0

B

ρg(L0−H)2−P0(L0−H)−L0P0=0\rho g(L_0 - H)^2 - P_0(L_0 - H) - L_0 P_0 = 0

C

ρg(L0−H)2+P0(L0−H)−L0P0=0\rho g(L_0 - H)^2 + P_0(L_0 - H) - L_0 P_0 = 0

Correct
D

ρg(L0−H)2−P0(L0−H)+L0P0=0\rho g(L_0 - H)^2 - P_0(L_0 - H) + L_0 P_0 = 0

Step-by-Step Solution

To determine the height HH of the water column inside the cylinder, we analyze the pressure and volume of the trapped air inside the cylinder before and after it is submerged.

1. Initial State of the Trapped Air:
Before the cylinder is submerged, the piston is removed and the hole at the top is sealed. The cylinder of total length L0L_0 and cross-sectional area AA is completely filled with air at atmospheric pressure P0P_0.

  • Initial Pressure: Pi=P0P_i = P_0
  • Initial Volume: Vi=AL0V_i = A L_0

2. Final State of the Trapped Air (in Equilibrium):
The cylinder is placed vertically such that its sealed top is flush with the water surface in the tank. Water enters from the open bottom up to a height HH.

  • The length of the trapped air column remaining at the top of the cylinder is:
    Lair=L0−HL_{\text{air}} = L_0 - H
  • The volume of the trapped air is:
    Vf=A(L0−H)V_f = A(L_0 - H)
  • The depth of the water-air interface below the free surface of the water in the tank is:
    h=L0−Hh = L_0 - H
  • Therefore, the hydrostatic pressure of the water at this interface (and hence the pressure of the trapped air) is:
    Pf=P0+ρg(L0−H)P_f = P_0 + \rho g (L_0 - H)

3. Applying Boyle's Law:
Assuming the process occurs at constant temperature (isothermal conditions), the ideal gas law gives:
PiVi=PfVfP_i V_i = P_f V_f

Substitute the initial and final values:
P0(AL0)=[P0+ρg(L0−H)]A(L0−H)P_0 (A L_0) = \left[ P_0 + \rho g (L_0 - H) \right] A (L_0 - H)

Canceling the common cross-sectional area AA:
P0L0=P0(L0−H)+ρg(L0−H)2P_0 L_0 = P_0(L_0 - H) + \rho g(L_0 - H)^2

Rearranging the terms:
ρg(L0−H)2+P0(L0−H)−L0P0=0\rho g(L_0 - H)^2 + P_0(L_0 - H) - L_0 P_0 = 0

Thus, the correct option is C.