JEE Challenger
More from Determinants

Harmonic Progression Terms and System of Linear Equations Solutions

Let p,q,rp, q, r be nonzero real numbers that are, respectively, the 10th10^{\text{th}}, 100th100^{\text{th}} and 1000th1000^{\text{th}} terms of a harmonic progression. Consider the system of linear equations
x+y+z=1x + y + z = 1
10x+100y+1000z=010x + 100y + 1000z = 0
qrx+pry+pqz=0.qr x + pr y + pq z = 0 .

List-IList-II(I) If qr=10, then the system of linear equations has(P) x=0, y=109, z=19 as a solution(II) If pr100, then the system of linear equations has(Q) x=109, y=19, z=0 as a solution(III) If pq10, then the system of linear equations has(R) infinitely many solutions(IV) If pq=10, then the system of linear equations has(S) no solution(T) at least one solution\begin{array}{ll} \text{\textbf{List-I}} & \text{\textbf{List-II}} \\ \text{(I) If } \frac{q}{r} = 10\text{, then the system of linear equations has} & \text{(P) } x = 0,\ y = \frac{10}{9},\ z = -\frac{1}{9} \text{ as a solution} \\ \text{(II) If } \frac{p}{r} \neq 100\text{, then the system of linear equations has} & \text{(Q) } x = \frac{10}{9},\ y = -\frac{1}{9},\ z = 0 \text{ as a solution} \\ \text{(III) If } \frac{p}{q} \neq 10\text{, then the system of linear equations has} & \text{(R) infinitely many solutions} \\ \text{(IV) If } \frac{p}{q} = 10\text{, then the system of linear equations has} & \text{(S) no solution} \\ & \text{(T) at least one solution} \end{array}

The correct option is:

Options

A

(I)(T);(II)(R);(III)(S);(IV)(T)(\text{I}) \rightarrow (\text{T}); (\text{II}) \rightarrow (\text{R}); (\text{III}) \rightarrow (\text{S}); (\text{IV}) \rightarrow (\text{T})

B

(I)(Q);(II)(S);(III)(S);(IV)(R)(\text{I}) \rightarrow (\text{Q}); (\text{II}) \rightarrow (\text{S}); (\text{III}) \rightarrow (\text{S}); (\text{IV}) \rightarrow (\text{R})

Correct
C

(I)(Q);(II)(R);(III)(P);(IV)(R)(\text{I}) \rightarrow (\text{Q}); (\text{II}) \rightarrow (\text{R}); (\text{III}) \rightarrow (\text{P}); (\text{IV}) \rightarrow (\text{R})

D

(I)(T);(II)(S);(III)(P);(IV)(T)(\text{I}) \rightarrow (\text{T}); (\text{II}) \rightarrow (\text{S}); (\text{III}) \rightarrow (\text{P}); (\text{IV}) \rightarrow (\text{T})

Step-by-Step Solution

To solve the problem, we first analyze the given Harmonic Progression (HP) and the system of linear equations.

Step 1: Harmonic Progression Relations

Since p,q,rp, q, r are the 10th10^{\text{th}}, 100th100^{\text{th}}, and 1000th1000^{\text{th}} terms of a Harmonic Progression, their reciprocals 1p,1q,1r\frac{1}{p}, \frac{1}{q}, \frac{1}{r} form an Arithmetic Progression (AP). Let aa be the first term and dd be the common difference of this AP. Then:

1p=a+9d\frac{1}{p} = a + 9d 1q=a+99d\frac{1}{q} = a + 99d 1r=a+999d\frac{1}{r} = a + 999d

Step 2: Simplifying the System of Linear Equations

The system of linear equations is:

  1. x+y+z=1x + y + z = 1
  2. 10x+100y+1000z=010x + 100y + 1000z = 0
  3. qrx+pry+pqz=0qr x + pr y + pq z = 0

Dividing equation (3) by pqrp q r (since p,q,r0p, q, r \neq 0), we get:

xp+yq+zr=0\frac{x}{p} + \frac{y}{q} + \frac{z}{r} = 0

Substitute the expressions for 1p,1q,1r\frac{1}{p}, \frac{1}{q}, \frac{1}{r} into this equation:

x(a+9d)+y(a+99d)+z(a+999d)=0x(a + 9d) + y(a + 99d) + z(a + 999d) = 0 a(x+y+z)+d(9x+99y+999z)=0— (4)a(x + y + z) + d(9x + 99y + 999z) = 0 \quad \text{--- (4)}

From equations (1) and (2):

  • x+y+z=1x + y + z = 1
  • 9x+99y+999z=(10x+100y+1000z)(x+y+z)=01=19x + 99y + 999z = (10x + 100y + 1000z) - (x + y + z) = 0 - 1 = -1

Substituting these into equation (4):

a(1)+d(1)=0    ad=0    a=da(1) + d(-1) = 0 \implies a - d = 0 \implies a = d

Step 3: Relating a=da = d to the Ratios of p,q,rp, q, r

Let's check the ratio pq\frac{p}{q}:

pq=1q1p=a+99da+9d\frac{p}{q} = \frac{\frac{1}{q}}{\frac{1}{p}} = \frac{a + 99d}{a + 9d}
  • If a=da = d, then pq=100d10d=10\frac{p}{q} = \frac{100d}{10d} = 10.
  • Conversely, if pq=10    a+99d=10(a+9d)    9a=9d    a=d\frac{p}{q} = 10 \implies a + 99d = 10(a + 9d) \implies 9a = 9d \implies a = d.

Similarly:

qr=10    a=d\frac{q}{r} = 10 \iff a = d pr=100    a=d\frac{p}{r} = 100 \iff a = d

Step 4: Analyzing the Solutions of the System

  • Case 1: a=da = d (i.e., qr=10\frac{q}{r} = 10, pq=10\frac{p}{q} = 10, or pr=100\frac{p}{r} = 100)
    Equation (3) is satisfied for all solutions of equations (1) and (2). Thus, the system reduces to 2 independent linear equations in 3 variables, which has infinitely many solutions.

    Let's test if (x=109,y=19,z=0)\left(x = \frac{10}{9}, y = -\frac{1}{9}, z = 0\right) is a solution:

    1. x+y+z=10919+0=1x + y + z = \frac{10}{9} - \frac{1}{9} + 0 = 1
    2. 10x+100y+1000z=10(109)+100(19)+0=010x + 100y + 1000z = 10\left(\frac{10}{9}\right) + 100\left(-\frac{1}{9}\right) + 0 = 0
    3. xp+yq+zr=109(10d)19(100d)+0=0\frac{x}{p} + \frac{y}{q} + \frac{z}{r} = \frac{10}{9}(10d) - \frac{1}{9}(100d) + 0 = 0

    Therefore, (x=109,y=19,z=0)\left(x = \frac{10}{9}, y = -\frac{1}{9}, z = 0\right) is indeed a solution.

  • Case 2: ada \neq d (i.e., pr100\frac{p}{r} \neq 100 or pq10\frac{p}{q} \neq 10)
    For any (x,y,z)(x, y, z) satisfying equations (1) and (2), the LHS of equation (3) evaluates to ad0a - d \neq 0. Thus, equation (3) cannot be satisfied simultaneously, meaning the system has no solution.

Step 5: Matching List-I to List-II

  1. (I) If qr=10\frac{q}{r} = 10, then a=da = d. The system has x=109,y=19,z=0x = \frac{10}{9}, y = -\frac{1}{9}, z = 0 as a solution \rightarrow (Q).
  2. (II) If pr100\frac{p}{r} \neq 100, then ada \neq d. The system has no solution \rightarrow (S).
  3. (III) If pq10\frac{p}{q} \neq 10, then ada \neq d. The system has no solution \rightarrow (S).
  4. (IV) If pq=10\frac{p}{q} = 10, then a=da = d. The system has infinitely many solutions \rightarrow (R).

Thus, the correct matching is: (I)(Q);(II)(S);(III)(S);(IV)(R)(\text{I}) \rightarrow (\text{Q}); \quad (\text{II}) \rightarrow (\text{S}); \quad (\text{III}) \rightarrow (\text{S}); \quad (\text{IV}) \rightarrow (\text{R})

This corresponds to Option B.