JEE Challenger
More from Units and Measurements

Dimensional Analysis of Visibility Distance in Fog

To find the distance dd over which a signal remains clearly visible in foggy weather, a railway engineer uses dimensional analysis and assumes that dd depends on the fog mass density ρ\rho, the light intensity SS (power/area), and the frequency ff. The engineer finds d∝S1/nd \propto S^{1/n}. The value of nn is

Official Numerical Answer3

Step-by-Step Solution

To determine the dependence of the visibility distance dd on the fog mass density ρ\rho, the light intensity SS, and the frequency ff, we use dimensional analysis.

The dimensions of the given physical quantities are:

  • Distance, dd: [d]=M0L1T0[d] = \text{M}^0 \text{L}^1 \text{T}^0
  • Mass density of fog, ρ\rho: [ρ]=MassVolume=M1L−3T0[\rho] = \frac{\text{Mass}}{\text{Volume}} = \text{M}^1 \text{L}^{-3} \text{T}^0
  • Intensity of light, SS (power per unit area): [S]=PowerArea=[Energy]/[Time]L2=M1L2T−3L2=M1L0T−3[S] = \frac{\text{Power}}{\text{Area}} = \frac{[\text{Energy}]/[\text{Time}]}{\text{L}^2} = \frac{\text{M}^1 \text{L}^2 \text{T}^{-3}}{\text{L}^2} = \text{M}^1 \text{L}^0 \text{T}^{-3}
  • Frequency, ff: [f]=1[Time]=M0L0T−1[f] = \frac{1}{[\text{Time}]} = \text{M}^0 \text{L}^0 \text{T}^{-1}

Assume the relation: d∝ρaSbfcd \propto \rho^a S^b f^c

Equating the dimensions on both sides: [d]=[ρ]a[S]b[f]c[d] = [\rho]^a [S]^b [f]^c M0L1T0=(M1L−3T0)a(M1L0T−3)b(M0L0T−1)c\text{M}^0 \text{L}^1 \text{T}^0 = (\text{M}^1 \text{L}^{-3} \text{T}^0)^a (\text{M}^1 \text{L}^0 \text{T}^{-3})^b (\text{M}^0 \text{L}^0 \text{T}^{-1})^c M0L1T0=Ma+bL−3aT−3b−c\text{M}^0 \text{L}^1 \text{T}^0 = \text{M}^{a+b} \text{L}^{-3a} \text{T}^{-3b-c}

Comparing the exponents of M\text{M}, L\text{L}, and T\text{T} on both sides:

  1. For L\text{L}: −3a=1  ⟹  a=−13-3a = 1 \implies a = -\frac{1}{3}
  2. For M\text{M}: a+b=0  ⟹  b=−a=13a + b = 0 \implies b = -a = \frac{1}{3}
  3. For T\text{T}: −3b−c=0  ⟹  c=−3b=−1-3b - c = 0 \implies c = -3b = -1

Hence, the relation between the variables is: d∝ρ−1/3S1/3f−1d \propto \rho^{-1/3} S^{1/3} f^{-1}

This gives: d∝S1/3d \propto S^{1/3}

Comparing this with the given proportional relation d∝S1/nd \propto S^{1/n}, we obtain: 1n=13  ⟹  n=3\frac{1}{n} = \frac{1}{3} \implies n = 3