JEE Challenger
More from Ray Optics and Optical Instruments

Deviation Angle Sensitivity in Split Refractive Index Prism

Consider a prism with apex angle θ=60∘\theta = 60^\circ. The refractive indices of its left and right halves are given by n1n_1 and n2n_2 (n2≥n1n_2 \ge n_1), respectively, as shown in the diagram. The angle of incidence ii is chosen such that incident light rays experience minimum deviation when n1=n2=n=1.5n_1 = n_2 = n = 1.5. For the case of unequal refractive indices where n1=nn_1 = n and n2=n+Δnn_2 = n + \Delta n (with Δn≪n\Delta n \ll n), the angle of emergence becomes e=i+Δee = i + \Delta e. Which of the following statements is/are correct?

Question Diagram 1

Options

A

The value of Δe\Delta e (in radians) is greater than that of Δn\Delta n

B

Δe\Delta e is proportional to Δn\Delta n

Correct
C

Δe\Delta e lies between 2.02.0 and 3.03.0 milliradians, if Δn=2.8×10−3\Delta n = 2.8 \times 10^{-3}

Correct
D

Δe\Delta e lies between 1.01.0 and 1.61.6 milliradians, if Δn=2.8×10−3\Delta n = 2.8 \times 10^{-3}

Step-by-Step Solution

To determine which of the statements are correct, we analyze the refraction of light through the two-part prism step-by-step.

Step 1: Minimum Deviation Condition in the Symmetric Prism

For a uniform prism of apex angle θ=60∘\theta = 60^\circ and refractive index n1=n2=n=1.5n_1 = n_2 = n = 1.5 undergoing minimum deviation:

  • The angle of refraction at the first surface is: r1=θ2=60∘2=30∘r_1 = \frac{\theta}{2} = \frac{60^\circ}{2} = 30^\circ
  • Using Snell's law at the first surface: sin⁡i=nsin⁡r1=1.5sin⁡30∘=1.5×0.5=0.75\sin i = n \sin r_1 = 1.5 \sin 30^\circ = 1.5 \times 0.5 = 0.75
  • The cosine of the angle of incidence ii is: cos⁡i=1−sin⁡2i=1−(0.75)2=1−916=74\cos i = \sqrt{1 - \sin^2 i} = \sqrt{1 - (0.75)^2} = \sqrt{1 - \frac{9}{16}} = \frac{\sqrt{7}}{4}

Under the condition of minimum deviation, the ray inside the prism travels perpendicular to the angle bisector (the vertical interface separating the two media).


Step 2: Refraction across the Interface and Second Surface

The interface between the two halves of the prism lies along the bisector of the apex angle θ\theta. Since the light ray inside the first half is perpendicular to this interface:

  1. The angle of incidence at the internal boundary is 0∘0^\circ (normal incidence).
  2. The ray passes straight into the second medium without any deviation at the internal boundary.
  3. Therefore, inside the right half of the prism, the ray continues along the same direction and strikes the second surface at an angle of incidence: r2=30∘r_2 = 30^\circ

For the second half with refractive index n2=n+Δnn_2 = n + \Delta n, Snell's law at the emergent surface gives: n2sin⁡r2=1⋅sin⁡en_2 \sin r_2 = 1 \cdot \sin e (n+Δn)sin⁡30∘=sin⁡(i+Δe)(n + \Delta n) \sin 30^\circ = \sin(i + \Delta e)


Step 3: Relation between Δe\Delta e and Δn\Delta n

Expanding the right-hand side using small angle approximation for Δe\Delta e (Δe≪1\Delta e \ll 1): nsin⁡30∘+Δnsin⁡30∘≈sin⁡i+cos⁡i⋅Δen \sin 30^\circ + \Delta n \sin 30^\circ \approx \sin i + \cos i \cdot \Delta e

Since nsin⁡30∘=sin⁡in \sin 30^\circ = \sin i, the equation simplifies to: Δnsin⁡30∘=cos⁡i⋅Δe\Delta n \sin 30^\circ = \cos i \cdot \Delta e

Δe=sin⁡30∘cos⁡iΔn=1/27/4Δn=27Δn\Delta e = \frac{\sin 30^\circ}{\cos i} \Delta n = \frac{1/2}{\sqrt{7}/4} \Delta n = \frac{2}{\sqrt{7}} \Delta n

Using the numerical value of 7≈2.646\sqrt{7} \approx 2.646: Δe≈22.646Δn≈0.756 Δn\Delta e \approx \frac{2}{2.646} \Delta n \approx 0.756 \, \Delta n


Step 4: Verification of the Options

  1. Option A: Δe≈0.756 Δn<Δn\Delta e \approx 0.756 \, \Delta n < \Delta n. Thus, Δe\Delta e is less than Δn\Delta n, making Statement A incorrect.

  2. Option B: Since Δe=(27)Δn\Delta e = \left(\frac{2}{\sqrt{7}}\right) \Delta n, Δe\Delta e is directly proportional to Δn\Delta n. Thus, Statement B is correct.

  3. Options C and D: For Δn=2.8×10−3\Delta n = 2.8 \times 10^{-3}: Δe=27×2.8×10−3=5.62.64575×10−3 rad≈2.116×10−3 rad=2.116 mrad\Delta e = \frac{2}{\sqrt{7}} \times 2.8 \times 10^{-3} = \frac{5.6}{2.64575} \times 10^{-3} \text{ rad} \approx 2.116 \times 10^{-3} \text{ rad} = 2.116 \text{ mrad}

    Since 2.116 mrad2.116\text{ mrad} lies between 2.0 mrad2.0\text{ mrad} and 3.0 mrad3.0\text{ mrad}:

    • Statement C is correct.
    • Statement D is incorrect.

Conclusion

The correct options are B and C.