To determine the correct choice, let us analyze both statements step-by-step.
Since a1,a2,a3,a4 are four distinct positive numbers in Geometric Progression (G.P.), we can express them as:
a1=a,a2=ar,a3=ar2,a4=ar3
where a>0, r>0, and r=1 (since the terms are distinct).
The partial sums b1,b2,b3,b4 are defined as:
b1=a1=a
b2=b1+a2=a+ar=a(1+r)
b3=b2+a3=a(1+r+r2)
b4=b3+a4=a(1+r+r2+r3)
Analysis of STATEMENT-1:
We need to test if b1,b2,b3,b4 are in Arithmetic Progression (A.P.) or Geometric Progression (G.P.).
-
Testing for A.P.:
The common differences between consecutive terms are:
b2−b1=a(1+r)−a=ar
b3−b2=a(1+r+r2)−a(1+r)=ar2
Since r=1 and a>0, we have ar=ar2. Thus, b2−b1=b3−b2, which implies b1,b2,b3,b4 are not in A.P.
-
Testing for G.P.:
The ratios between consecutive terms are:
b1b2=aa(1+r)=1+r
b2b3=a(1+r)a(1+r+r2)=1+r1+r+r2
If b1,b2,b3,b4 were in G.P., then:
b1b2=b2b3⟹1+r=1+r1+r+r2
(1+r)2=1+r+r2⟹1+2r+r2=1+r+r2⟹r=0
However, r>0 because a1,a2,a3,a4 are positive numbers. Thus, b1b2=b2b3, which implies b1,b2,b3,b4 are not in G.P.
Hence, STATEMENT-1 is True.
Analysis of STATEMENT-2:
We need to test if b1,b2,b3,b4 are in Harmonic Progression (H.P.).
If b1,b2,b3,b4 are in H.P., then their reciprocals b11,b21,b31,b41 must be in A.P., which requires:
b21−b11=b31−b21
Evaluating both sides:
LHS=a(1+r)1−a1=a(1+r)1−(1+r)=a(1+r)−r
RHS=a(1+r+r2)1−a(1+r)1=a(1+r)(1+r+r2)(1+r)−(1+r+r2)=a(1+r)(1+r+r2)−r2
Equating LHS and RHS:
a(1+r)−r=a(1+r)(1+r+r2)−r2
Since a>0 and r>0, we can cancel a(1+r)−r from both sides:
1=1+r+r2r⟹1+r+r2=r⟹1+r2=0
Since r is a real positive number, 1+r2=0 has no real solutions.
Hence, b1,b2,b3,b4 are not in H.P., so STATEMENT-2 is False.
Conclusion:
- STATEMENT-1 is True.
- STATEMENT-2 is False.
This corresponds to Option C.