JEE Challenger
More from Matrices

Determinant and Null Space of Commuting Matrices Relation

Suppose MM and NN are two 3×33 \times 3 matrices satisfying MN=NMMN = NM. Furthermore, suppose M≠N2M \neq N^2 and M2=N4M^2 = N^4. Then

Options

A

determinant of (M2+MN2)(M^2 + MN^2) is 00

Correct
B

there exists a 3×33 \times 3 non-zero matrix UU such that (M2+MN2)U(M^2 + MN^2)U is the zero matrix

Correct
C

determinant of (M2+MN2)≥1(M^2 + MN^2) \ge 1

D

for any 3×33 \times 3 matrix UU, if (M2+MN2)U(M^2 + MN^2)U equals the zero matrix, then UU must be the zero matrix

Step-by-Step Solution

To determine the correct statements, we analyze the given matrix equations step-by-step:

  1. Commutativity of Matrices: Given that MM and NN are 3×33 \times 3 matrices with MN=NMMN = NM, it follows that MM commutes with any power of NN, including N2N^2: MN2=N2MM N^2 = N^2 M

  2. Factorization using Commutativity: Given M2=N4M^2 = N^4, we can write: M2−N4=OM^2 - N^4 = O Since MM and N2N^2 commute, the difference of squares can be factored as: (M−N2)(M+N2)=(M+N2)(M−N2)=O(M - N^2)(M + N^2) = (M + N^2)(M - N^2) = O

  3. Existence of a Non-Zero Matrix UU: Consider the matrix U=M−N2U = M - N^2. Since it is given that M≠N2M \neq N^2, we have: U=M−N2≠OU = M - N^2 \neq O Now, evaluate the product (M2+MN2)U(M^2 + MN^2)U: (M2+MN2)U=M(M+N2)(M−N2)(M^2 + MN^2)U = M(M + N^2)(M - N^2) Using the fact that (M+N2)(M−N2)=O(M + N^2)(M - N^2) = O: (M2+MN2)U=M⋅O=O(M^2 + MN^2)U = M \cdot O = O Thus, there exists a non-zero 3×33 \times 3 matrix U=M−N2U = M - N^2 such that: (M2+MN2)U=O(M^2 + MN^2)U = O Therefore, Option (B) is correct, and Option (D) is incorrect.

  4. Determinant of (M2+MN2)(M^2 + MN^2): If the matrix (M2+MN2)(M^2 + MN^2) were invertible, we could multiply both sides of (M2+MN2)U=O(M^2 + MN^2)U = O by (M2+MN2)−1(M^2 + MN^2)^{-1} to get: U=(M2+MN2)−1O=OU = (M^2 + MN^2)^{-1} O = O This contradicts the fact that U≠OU \neq O.

    Therefore, (M2+MN2)(M^2 + MN^2) must be a singular matrix, which means: det⁡(M2+MN2)=0\det(M^2 + MN^2) = 0 Therefore, Option (A) is correct, and Option (C) is incorrect.

Correct Options: (A) and (B)