JEE Challenger
More from Structure of Atom

Correct Statements Regarding Atomic Orbitals and Energies

Which of the following statement(s) is/are true ?

A. If two orbitals have the same value of (n+l)(n + l), the orbital with lower value of nn will have lower energy. B. Energies of the orbitals in the same subshell increase with increase in atomic number. C. The size of 2px2p_x orbital is less than the size of 3px3p_x orbital. D. Among 5f,6s,4d,5p5f, 6s, 4d, 5p and 5d5d orbitals, none of the orbitals have 2 radial nodes.

Choose the correct answer from the options given below :

Options

A

A, B and C only

B

A and C only

Correct
C

C and D only

D

A only

Step-by-Step Solution

To determine which of the given statements are true, let us analyze each statement individually:

  1. Statement A: If two orbitals have the same value of (n+l)(n + l), the orbital with lower value of nn will have lower energy.

    • According to the (n+l)(n + l) rule (Bohr-Bury rule):
      • The energy of an orbital increases with an increase in the value of (n+l)(n + l).
      • When two orbitals have the same value of (n+l)(n + l), the orbital with a lower value of nn (principal quantum number) is situated closer to the nucleus and possesses lower energy.
    • Therefore, Statement A is TRUE.
  2. Statement B: Energies of the orbitals in the same subshell increase with increase in atomic number.

    • As the atomic number (ZZ) increases, the nuclear charge increases.
    • A higher nuclear charge results in a stronger electrostatic force of attraction between the nucleus and the electron, which lowers (makes more negative) the energy of the orbitals.
    • Thus, the energy of orbitals in a given subshell decreases (becomes more negative) as the atomic number increases.
    • Therefore, Statement B is FALSE.
  3. Statement C: The size of 2px2p_x orbital is less than the size of 3px3p_x orbital.

    • The size of an atomic orbital is primarily determined by the principal quantum number (nn).
    • As nn increases, the region where the electron is most likely to be found extends further from the nucleus, increasing the size of the orbital.
    • Since n=2n = 2 for the 2px2p_x orbital and n=3n = 3 for the 3px3p_x orbital, the size of 2px2p_x is smaller than that of 3px3p_x.
    • Therefore, Statement C is TRUE.
  4. Statement D: Among 5f,6s,4d,5p5f, 6s, 4d, 5p and 5d5d orbitals, none of the orbitals have 2 radial nodes.

    • The number of radial nodes for an orbital is given by the formula: Radial nodes=nl1\text{Radial nodes} = n - l - 1
    • Calculating the number of radial nodes for each orbital:
      • For 5f5f: n=5,l=3    Radial nodes=531=1n = 5, l = 3 \implies \text{Radial nodes} = 5 - 3 - 1 = 1
      • For 6s6s: n=6,l=0    Radial nodes=601=5n = 6, l = 0 \implies \text{Radial nodes} = 6 - 0 - 1 = 5
      • For 4d4d: n=4,l=2    Radial nodes=421=1n = 4, l = 2 \implies \text{Radial nodes} = 4 - 2 - 1 = 1
      • For 5p5p: n=5,l=1    Radial nodes=511=3n = 5, l = 1 \implies \text{Radial nodes} = 5 - 1 - 1 = 3
      • For 5d5d: n=5,l=2    Radial nodes=521=2n = 5, l = 2 \implies \text{Radial nodes} = 5 - 2 - 1 = 2
    • Since the 5d5d orbital has 2 radial nodes, the claim that "none of the orbitals have 2 radial nodes" is incorrect.
    • Therefore, Statement D is FALSE.

Conclusion: Only statements A and C are true.

This corresponds to the option A and C only.

Correct Statements Regarding Atomic Orbitals and Energies | Chemistry PYQ Solution - JEE Challenger