Comparison of Third Ionization Energy and CFSE of Cobalt Complexes
Given below are two statements :
Statement I : Among and , the energy required to remove the third valence electron is highest for and lowest for .
Statement II : The correct order of the following complexes in terms of CFSE is .
In the light of the above statements, choose the correct answer from the options given below :
Options
Both Statement I and Statement II are true
Both Statement I and Statement II are false
Statement I is true but Statement II is false
Statement I is false but Statement II is true
Topics & Concepts
Step-by-Step Solution
To determine the correctness of the given statements, let us analyze each statement individually:
Analysis of Statement I:
The third ionization energy () corresponds to the energy required to remove the third electron from a doubly charged gaseous cation:
Let us examine the electronic configurations of the oxidation states for the given -series transition elements:
-
Zinc (, ):
- Ground state configuration:
- configuration:
- Removing the 3rd electron requires breaking a completely filled, extra-stable subshell. Hence, has the highest among all -series transition elements ().
-
Scandium (, ):
- Ground state configuration:
- configuration:
- Removing the 3rd electron yields the extremely stable noble gas configuration (). Therefore, the energy required is the lowest ().
-
Manganese (, ) and Copper (, ):
- configuration: ()
- configuration: ()
Comparing the third ionization energies:
Thus, among and , is highest for and lowest for .
Therefore, Statement I is TRUE.
Analysis of Statement II:
The magnitude of the Crystal Field Splitting Energy (CFSE), represented by the octahedral splitting parameter , depends on:
-
Oxidation state of the central metal ion: Higher oxidation state results in greater effective nuclear charge (), drawing ligands closer and causing greater splitting ().
- Comparing () and ():
-
Nature of the ligand (Spectrochemical Series): Stronger field ligands produce larger crystal field splitting energy ().
- According to the spectrochemical series: (ethylenediamine is a bidentate strong-field ligand).
- Comparing and :
Combining these trends, the correct increasing order of CFSE () is:
Therefore, Statement II is TRUE.
Conclusion:
Since both Statement I and Statement II are true, the correct option is A.