JEE Challenger
More from Structure of Atom

Comparison of Orbital Energies in Hydrogen and Lithium Atoms

The 2s and the 2p orbital energies of hydrogen atom are E2s(H)E_{2\text{s}}(\text{H}) and E2p(H)E_{2\text{p}}(\text{H}), respectively. The 2s and the 2p orbital energies of lithium atom are E2s(Li)E_{2\text{s}}(\text{Li}) and E2p(Li)E_{2\text{p}}(\text{Li}), respectively. The correct option(s) about the orbital energies is(are)

Options

A

E2s(Li)<E2p(Li)E_{2\text{s}}(\text{Li}) < E_{2\text{p}}(\text{Li})

Correct
B

E2s(H)=E2p(H)E_{2\text{s}}(\text{H}) = E_{2\text{p}}(\text{H})

Correct
C

E2p(H)<E2s(Li)E_{2\text{p}}(\text{H}) < E_{2\text{s}}(\text{Li})

D

E2s(H)>E2s(Li)E_{2\text{s}}(\text{H}) > E_{2\text{s}}(\text{Li})

Correct

Step-by-Step Solution

To determine the correct options regarding orbital energies, let us analyze the behavior of single-electron and multi-electron atomic systems.

  1. Hydrogen Atom (H\text{H}): Single-Electron System

    • For single-electron species like the hydrogen atom, the energy of an orbital depends solely on the principal quantum number nn and is independent of the azimuthal quantum number ll.
    • Using the Bohr model / quantum mechanical model formula for hydrogen: En(H)=13.6n2 eVE_n(\text{H}) = -\frac{13.6}{n^2} \text{ eV}
    • For n=2n = 2: E2s(H)=E2p(H)=13.622 eV=3.4 eVE_{2\text{s}}(\text{H}) = E_{2\text{p}}(\text{H}) = -\frac{13.6}{2^2} \text{ eV} = -3.4 \text{ eV}
    • Therefore, Option (B) is correct.
  2. Lithium Atom (Li\text{Li}): Multi-Electron System

    • For multi-electron atoms like lithium (Z=3Z = 3), the energy of an orbital depends on both nn and ll due to electron-electron repulsion and shielding (screening) effects.
    • The 2s2\text{s} orbital has greater penetrating power than the 2p2\text{p} orbital, which means a 2s2\text{s} electron spends more time closer to the nucleus and experiences a greater effective nuclear charge (ZeffZ_{\text{eff}}) than a 2p2\text{p} electron.
    • A higher ZeffZ_{\text{eff}} results in stronger electrostatic attraction, making the energy more negative (lower energy level): E2s(Li)<E2p(Li)E_{2\text{s}}(\text{Li}) < E_{2\text{p}}(\text{Li})
    • Therefore, Option (A) is correct.
  3. Comparison between H\text{H} and Li\text{Li} Orbitals

    • In the hydrogen atom (Z=1Z = 1), the 2s2\text{s} electron experiences a nuclear charge of Z=1Z = 1.
    • In the lithium atom (Z=3Z = 3), the 2s2\text{s} electron is shielded by the two 1s1\text{s} electrons, resulting in an effective nuclear charge Zeff1.3Z_{\text{eff}} \approx 1.3 (Slater's rules: Zeff=32×0.85=1.3Z_{\text{eff}} = 3 - 2 \times 0.85 = 1.3).
    • Since Zeff(Li)>Zeff(H)Z_{\text{eff}}(\text{Li}) > Z_{\text{eff}}(\text{H}), the 2s2\text{s} orbital in lithium is more strongly bound (has lower energy) than the 2s2\text{s} orbital in hydrogen: E2s(Li)<E2s(H)    E2s(H)>E2s(Li)E_{2\text{s}}(\text{Li}) < E_{2\text{s}}(\text{H}) \implies E_{2\text{s}}(\text{H}) > E_{2\text{s}}(\text{Li})
    • Numerically, E2s(H)=3.4 eVE_{2\text{s}}(\text{H}) = -3.4 \text{ eV} while E2s(Li)=5.39 eVE_{2\text{s}}(\text{Li}) = -5.39 \text{ eV} (equal to the negative of the first ionization energy of Li\text{Li}).
    • Therefore, Option (D) is correct.
  4. Evaluation of Option (C)

    • Since E2p(H)=3.4 eVE_{2\text{p}}(\text{H}) = -3.4 \text{ eV} and E2s(Li)=5.39 eVE_{2\text{s}}(\text{Li}) = -5.39 \text{ eV}, we have: E2p(H)>E2s(Li)E_{2\text{p}}(\text{H}) > E_{2\text{s}}(\text{Li})
    • Therefore, Option (C) is incorrect.

Thus, the correct options are (A), (B), and (D).

Comparison of Orbital Energies in Hydrogen and Lithium Atoms | Chemistry PYQ Solution - JEE Challenger