Comparison of Orbital Energies in Hydrogen and Lithium Atoms
The 2s and the 2p orbital energies of hydrogen atom are and , respectively. The 2s and the 2p orbital energies of lithium atom are and , respectively. The correct option(s) about the orbital energies is(are)
Options
A
Correct
B
Correct
C
D
Correct
Topics & Concepts
Step-by-Step Solution
To determine the correct options regarding orbital energies, let us analyze the behavior of single-electron and multi-electron atomic systems.
-
Hydrogen Atom (): Single-Electron System
- For single-electron species like the hydrogen atom, the energy of an orbital depends solely on the principal quantum number and is independent of the azimuthal quantum number .
- Using the Bohr model / quantum mechanical model formula for hydrogen:
- For :
- Therefore, Option (B) is correct.
-
Lithium Atom (): Multi-Electron System
- For multi-electron atoms like lithium (), the energy of an orbital depends on both and due to electron-electron repulsion and shielding (screening) effects.
- The orbital has greater penetrating power than the orbital, which means a electron spends more time closer to the nucleus and experiences a greater effective nuclear charge () than a electron.
- A higher results in stronger electrostatic attraction, making the energy more negative (lower energy level):
- Therefore, Option (A) is correct.
-
Comparison between and Orbitals
- In the hydrogen atom (), the electron experiences a nuclear charge of .
- In the lithium atom (), the electron is shielded by the two electrons, resulting in an effective nuclear charge (Slater's rules: ).
- Since , the orbital in lithium is more strongly bound (has lower energy) than the orbital in hydrogen:
- Numerically, while (equal to the negative of the first ionization energy of ).
- Therefore, Option (D) is correct.
-
Evaluation of Option (C)
- Since and , we have:
- Therefore, Option (C) is incorrect.
Thus, the correct options are (A), (B), and (D).