JEE Challenger
More from Ray Optics and Optical Instruments

Apparent Speed of Falling Ball Observed by an Underwater Observer

A ball is dropped from a height of 20 m20\text{ m} above the surface of water in a lake. The refractive index of water is 4/34/3. A fish inside the lake, in the line of fall of the ball, is looking at the ball. At an instant, when the ball is 12.8 m12.8\text{ m} above the water surface, the fish sees the speed of ball as
[Take g=10 m/s2.][\text{Take } g = 10\text{ m/s}^2.]

Options

A

9 m/s9\text{ m/s}

B

12 m/s12\text{ m/s}

C

16 m/s16\text{ m/s}

Correct
D

21.33 m/s21.33\text{ m/s}

Step-by-Step Solution

To find the apparent speed of the falling ball as observed by the fish, we first determine the actual speed of the ball at the given instant.

Step 1: Calculate the actual speed of the ball
The ball is dropped from an initial height of h0=20 mh_0 = 20\text{ m} above the water surface.
At the given instant, the ball is at a height of h=12.8 mh = 12.8\text{ m} above the surface.

The downward distance covered by the ball is:
s=h0−h=20 m−12.8 m=7.2 ms = h_0 - h = 20\text{ m} - 12.8\text{ m} = 7.2\text{ m}

Using the kinematic equation for free fall from rest (u=0u = 0):
v2=u2+2gsv^2 = u^2 + 2gs
v2=0+2(10 m/s2)(7.2 m)=144 m2/s2v^2 = 0 + 2(10\text{ m/s}^2)(7.2\text{ m}) = 144\text{ m}^2/\text{s}^2
v=144=12 m/sv = \sqrt{144} = 12\text{ m/s}

Thus, the actual downward speed of the ball is v=12 m/sv = 12\text{ m/s}.


Step 2: Calculate the apparent speed seen by the fish
Let the distance of the ball above the water surface at any instant be yy.
Since the light rays travel from the rarer medium (air, μair=1\mu_{\text{air}} = 1) to the denser medium (water, μwater=μ=43\mu_{\text{water}} = \mu = \frac{4}{3}), the apparent height y′y' of the ball as seen by an underwater observer is given by:
y′=μyy' = \mu y

Differentiating both sides with respect to time tt:
dy′dt=μdydt\frac{dy'}{dt} = \mu \frac{dy}{dt}

Taking the magnitude, the apparent speed v′v' is:
v′=μvv' = \mu v

Substituting the values μ=43\mu = \frac{4}{3} and v=12 m/sv = 12\text{ m/s}:
v′=43×12 m/s=16 m/sv' = \frac{4}{3} \times 12\text{ m/s} = 16\text{ m/s}

Therefore, the fish observes the ball falling at a speed of 16 m/s16\text{ m/s}.

Correct Option: C